Munich Re logo
Not if, but how

Explore Munich Re Group

Get to know our Group companies, branches and subsidiaries worldwide.

Infographic: Legal system abuse
A proactive approach to understand and address the issue of legal system abuse
Infographic: Legal system abuse
© Tetra Images / Getty Images
    alt txt

    properties.trackTitle

    properties.trackSubtitle

    Consumers, businesses, and insurers are increasingly fraught by the impact of legal system abuse and the resulting skyrocketing verdicts. Legal system abuse, often referred to as social inflation, applies to a variety of tactics the trial bar uses to initiate more lawsuits, drive up litigation expense costs and settlements for defendants, and secure higher verdicts.
    $3,300+
    Average household pays due to abusive litigation that raises costs of products and services¹
    300%
    Rise in Nuclear Verdicts® in 2019 from annual average 2001-2010²
    375
    Typical days to close claims with attorneys, compared to 168 days without attorneys³

    Drivers of legal system abuse

    Several social, political, legal, and economic drivers contribute to making legal system abuse one of the major emerging risks the insurance industry faces today.
    Desensitization to large verdicts
    Needed repairs to the civil justice system
    Diminished value of money
    Class action lawsuits
    Litigation funding
    Social media and legal advertising
    Public distrust of corporate defendants/attorneys
    Generational shift in jury pools
    Increase in medical expenses
    Jury anchoring
    Venue shopping

    Nuclear Verdicts®

    “Nuclear Verdicts” are defined as verdicts over $10mn. A new term emerging – “thermonuclear” verdicts – are far exceeding the $10mn threshold and can only be explained by emotional or punitive juror motives.

    Top 10 states by cumulative Nuclear Verdicts (>$10mn) 2010-2019

    Source: Institute for Legal Reform. 2022.4

    Largest jury verdicts of 2022

    Source: VerdictSearch. 2023.5

    Litigation funding

    Third-party litigation funding (TPLF) is surging, with more than $11bn of capital invested in the United States.6 This driver of legal system abuse is an arrangement where a funder that is not a party to a lawsuit provides funding to a plaintiff or law firm in exchange for an interest in the potential award in a lawsuit. Plaintiffs do not have to repay the funding if their lawsuit is not successful.
    Litigation funding
    Sources
    1 The US Tort System Costs $443 Billion, US Chamber of Commerce, The Institute for Legal Reform, January 5, 2023 The U.S. Tort System Costs $443 Billion | ILR (instituteforlegalreform.com
    2 Pain, D. 2020. Social Inflation: Navigating the evolving claims environment. Geneva Association. Retrieved: January 23, 2023. (https://www.genevaassociation.org/sites/default/files/research-topics-document-type/pdf_public/social_inflation_web_171220.pdf)
    3 Insurance Research Council. 2022. Public Attitudes on Litigation Trends and the Role of Attorneys in Auto Insurance Claims. Retrieved: January 26, 2023. (https://www.insurance-research.org/research-publications/countrywide-patterns-auto-injury-claims)
    4 U.S. Chamber of Commerce Institute for Legal Reform. 2022. Nuclear Verdicts: Trends, Causes, and Solutions. Retrieved: January 22, 2023. (https://instituteforlegalreform.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/NuclearVerdicts_RGB_FINAL.pdf)
    5 Law.com VerdictSearch. 2023. Featured Verdicts. Retrieved: January 24, 2023. (https://verdictsearch.com/state/all/)
    6 American Property Casualty Insurance Association. 2023. Legal System Abuse Hurts Families and Affects Jobs. Retrieved: January 23, 2023. (https://www.apci.org/legal-system-abuse/)
    Experts
    Maura Freiwald
    Maura Freiwald
    Head of Casualty
    Munich Re US

    Related Articles

    Newsletter

    Stay ahead of the curve with exclusive insights and industry updates! Subscribe to our Munich Re Insights Newsletter for a front-row seat to the latest trends in risk management, expert analyses and assessments, market insights, and innovations in the insurance industry. Join our community of forward-thinkers at Munich Re and empower your journey towards a more resilient future.