© [M] Munich Re [P1] AlexSecret / Getty Images - AI-modified

Climate Change - why incremental change isn't enough (S4E3)

Reinsurance Rendezvous podcast

    Track image

    0:00
    0:00
    By pressing the start button, Liberated Syndication Inc. (“Libsyn”) will process personal data about your use of the player. More information can be found in Libsyn’s privacy notice.

    Listen and subscribe on: Spotify | Apple

    About this episode

    Are we preparing for the natural hazard risks we’re facing today – or the ones that are rapidly emerging? That's the challenge at the heart of this episode.

    Join host Scott Hawkins as he speaks with Andrew Gissing, CEO of Natural Hazards Research Australia, about why incremental change is no longer enough.

    As climate patterns shift, exposure grows and affordability pressures intensify, the conversation explores what a more transformational, long-term approach to managing natural hazard risk could look like for Australia.

    One message is clear: the decisions we make today will shape outcomes for decades to come.

    While Munich Holdings of Australasia Pty Ltd (“MHA”) has used its discretion, best judgement and every reasonable effort in compiling the information and components contained in these podcasts, it may not be held liable for the completeness, correctness, topicality and technical accuracy of any information contained herein. Listeners should form their own opinions and seek their own counsel and professional advice on any subject matter discussed to verify the accuracy and completeness of any information and to determine its applicability to any particular circumstances.  MHA and the Munich Re Group make no representations or warranties of any kind (express or implied) as to the reliability, accuracy or completeness of the information, content, materials, products or services discussed in this podcast.   

    00:12 Teaser audio extract

    “Year on year, how we manage natural hazard risk in Australia is just not going to cut it anymore. We can't just be thinking about ‘the next fire season’ or ‘the next cyclone season’ and the improvements that we'll incrementally make in between. 

    We know that this worsening natural hazard risk is going to see an increase in not just the everyday emergencies, but an increase in the large catastrophes, where are going to have these multibillion-dollar losses, hundreds of people, death tolls, et cetera. These are the big events that we sit up at night, really worrying about.

    And so we need to be transforming our approach. We need to be saying, ‘What are those new capabilities that we need?’ ‘What are those big changes that we need to be making to really make sure that we're going to be prepared for the worsening risk of the future?’”

    01:02 Episode begins 

    Andy McLean

    Hello, and welcome to Reinsurance Rendezvous, a podcast by Munich Re. 

    I'm Andy McLean, a podcast producer based in Sydney, and we have got some terrific guests coming your way soon. So, make sure you stay subscribed or following Reinsurance Rendezvous on your podcast channel of choice – and while you're there, we love hearing from listeners too, so do feel free to leave us a rating, a comment, or a review. 

    Okay, let's get straight into today's chat. Joining me, as always, we have Scott Hawkins, the Managing Director of Munich Re Australasia. Hello again, Scott. 

    Scott Hawkins  01:35

    Hi Andy.

    Andy McLean  01:36

    And we have our special guest today, which is the CEO of Natural Hazards Australia, Andrew Gissing. Welcome, Andrew.

    Andrew Gissing  01:43

    G'day Andy.

    Andy McLean  01:43

    Last episode we took a global look at climate and natural hazards. Today we're looking closer to home. We're going to ask, “what does changing climate and worsening risk really mean for us here in Australia?” Any opening reflections, Scott?

    Scott Hawkins  02:01

    I mean, reflecting on the last podcast, Andy, I think what we were really discussing was: we're behind the curve of where we want to be when it comes to transitioning to a net zero environment and the implications that will have to a changing climate. And then the hazards that we face, if we think about it, we basically said it's a bit of a strategy of “hope and a hockey stick”. That we really – at the back end of our period to 2050 – we [need to] do much more than we're doing already.

    Andy McLean  02.28

    Andrew, any thoughts?

    Andrew Gissing  02:28

    When we talk about worsening natural hazard risk (and climate change is obviously a big part of that –  for example, seeing worsening fire conditions, more frequent severe weather events) but we also talk about those other things, which are increasing our risk here in Australia. 

    So, you know, land use developments in hazard-prone areas, environmental degradation, all these things, which are worsening our risk, which means in future decades we potentially are further behind the eight ball, and we really need to be getting what we call “ahead and ready” and thinking about what are the step changes we need to be making now in investing in those, such that in 10–20 years we're going to be prepared for this worsening natural hazard risk environment.

    Andy McLean  03:13

    So, just for clarity, Andrew, when we talk about “worsening risk”, what do we mean?

    Andrew Gissing  03:19

    So it's a variety of different factors which are influencing our natural hazard risk here in Australia and globally. 

    So, firstly, climate change. We know our global temperatures are clearly increasing, and the influence they're having on natural hazards. We're seeing them here in Australia. The 2022 floods is a great example, but also the fires in Black Summer, there was attribution to climate change there as well. 

    But also we're seeing the increase in our urban development in at-risk areas. This is obviously increasing the loss exposure profiles, meaning more people and more assets are at risk when natural hazards occur.

    And environmental degradation as well. So our environment is not what it once was. If we think about our catchments, for example: deforestation. We now are able to have more water flowing into our streams than historically occurred hundreds of years ago, and there's also the opportunity there to be embracing First Nations knowledges into the future to help us to transform our approaches to managing natural hazard risk.

    Andy McLean  04:22

    Scott, what about from an affordability perspective? This must be adding enormous pressure from an insurance perspective.

    Scott Hawkins  

    Absolutely, Andy. And if I think about in a couple of areas. One is, as Andrew quite rightly said, we're building in more exposed areas, but we have a housing crisis, so we're trying to build more things, and the problem with that is we're building more things in the most exposed areas, and that's really coming from an affordability point now, where what makes that even worse, it's often the lower socioeconomic parts of society who are being placed in the most harm's way environments, and that, of course, does create a huge affordability problem. 

    Andy McLean  05:01

    Andrew, you've talked previously about the need to “get out of a cycle of change”. What's wrong with incremental change?

    Andrew Gissing  05:10

    Well, incremental change is okay. Year on year, how we manage natural hazard risk in Australia is just not going to cut it anymore. We can't just be thinking about ‘the next fire season’ or ‘the next cyclone season’ and the improvements that we'll incrementally make in between. 

    We know that this worsening natural hazard risk is going to see an increase in not just the everyday emergencies, but an increase in the large catastrophes, where are going to have these multibillion-dollar losses, hundreds of people, death tolls, et cetera. These are the big events that we sit up at night, really worrying about.

    And so we need to be transforming our approach. We need to be saying, ‘What are those new capabilities that we need?’ ‘What are those big changes that we need to be making to really make sure that we're going to be prepared for the worsening risk of the future? Not just trying to play catch up at the time, and not having huge gaps in our capability to be able to manage these events, but truly be ahead of the curve and be prepared.

    Andy McLean  06:11

    Yeah, so what we're talking about here is “transformational change”, not incremental change.

    Scott Hawkins  06:17

    Yes, I think what we need to do is make the decisions now based on the consequences of those decisions well into the future. 

    To use a concrete example, we have a housing crisis in Australia. So we make decisions like pausing building codes, so building can happen quicker, but now we're starting to build things for the next 50 years not to the standard that they need to be for the environment to which they're going to be part of and those sort of decisions are going to compound the problem going forward rather than taking a bit of a harder decision today for the benefit of the future.

    Andy McLean  06:49

    That sounds to me like we're requiring cultural change too, right? So that we, if we are going to plan decades ahead, we need to start rethinking how we're approaching this?

    Scott Hawkins  07:00

    We do, and when we're making some of these decisions, we're making them - I wouldn't say in “a knee-jerk reaction”, but we're making it to solve one problem without thinking about the bigger system that we're in, and what other problems stem from that. And what we're not realising is that by trying to fix a short-term problem, we're making it even bigger, long-term problem. So a little bit like “kicking the can down the road”.

    Andrew Gissing  07:24

    I agree with what Scott is saying, and I think the natural hazard risk landscape, a lot of the influences that we're really talking about, how risk is defined, a lot of them are being responsive to shorter-term political issues that are arising in our country in other areas. 

    There's a great book in the US called The Geography of Risk, and it talks about the evolution of communities in hurricane-prone areas. And after, you know, these communities are built, they're built in swamps, they're built for cheap prices in these areas, and developers are able to benefit.

    After they have the big hurricane, development is ceased. Then only a few years later, development restarts due to political pressures, and then it's back on.

    And then this growth of development over time, you know, we see that here in Australia too. You know, in terms of when we look at mitigation, for example, our biggest mitigation investments and uplifts in our capability tend to be directly after events, and they're responsive to the recommendations that are made from various inquiries. 

    What we lack here in Australia is this system of innovation, where – separate from being responsive to events – we have this ongoing system of innovation around disaster mitigation and risk reduction.

    Andy McLean  08:46

    Are we seeing that innovation elsewhere overseas?

    Andrew Gissing  08:49

    I think it is a general problem throughout the disaster risk reduction system, and what tends to happen with innovation in Australia is it relies on “champions”. 

    So without those champions being present, innovation isn't present unless there's something else to force it, like an event to actually occur. 

    One of the challenges that we have, particularly in the research and science space, is to be able to build out this broader innovation system, such that innovations are being championed, that we've got more piloting of different technologies, different approaches learning from that separate from our learnings that we're generating from events.

    Andy McLean  09:25

    And Scott, from an insurance perspective, how can insurers and reinsurers contribute to this spirit of innovation? 

    Scott Hawkins  09:35

    I mean, we can contribute in a rather unique way. We have a lot of the information that's required to actually inform those decisions going forward, but what we don't have is the ability to necessarily directly influence those decisions. 

    So I think we're “a gatekeeper of information” that we're very much prepared to share – and that's already happening in things like the Hazard Insurance Partnership – but utilising that information to make broader decisions which are outside of the ecosystem of insurance.

    Andy McLean  10:05

    And for listeners who perhaps aren't in the insurance industry, but they want to do something practical, perhaps in their own household, can you offer any kind of effective economical practical tips for households?

    Andrew Gissing  10:21

    Well, there's plenty of great research and science that looks at this. I've been particularly interested in some of the work coming out of California, and we've been doing some recent work at Natural Hazard Research Australia, particularly looking at “defensible space” around homes through some work at University of Tasmania. Also looking at research around incentives for people to make retrofitting of their homes there too.

    But a really interesting thing coming out of California (and they're really just designing the regulation and trying to get that in place after the fires) is this whole notion of “zone zero” around homes, and we do have defensible space guidelines here in Australia as well, but these are quite unique globally, and a huge change. 

    Essentially, what zone zero is: it's the removal of combustible materials from the base of an asset out to about 1.5 metres away. And what the science is really saying is that embers hit the side of the building, they fall directly at the bottom of the building, they catch light on any of the combustible materials, and then they consume the building. 

    And there's a really great paper that's been published recently that really looks at this and says it is the most effective way of reducing fire risk in the US, and likely to have a significant impact here in Australia too, of reducing this combustible material at the base of these buildings. 

    Obviously, you know, if I also look at things like flood, there's lots of things that can be done using flood resilient building materials throughout a home. I often just walk into flood affected businesses, and the first thing I say is “Get rid of the carpet”, you know, like “Just go for a hardboard finish, for example, or a cement finish, because we know how valuable carpets are, and how valuable they are to replace.”

    Andy McLean  12:03

    Obviously we're in an environment where cost-of-living pressures are really biting, and we've already talked about insurance affordability issues. So, how do we make this realistic for households?

    Scott Hawkins  12:16

    Yeah, so Andy, I think here what we need to focus on are: what are affordable things that actually make a difference? 

    So there's some very unaffordable things we can do to mitigate an individual property, which may not make a big difference in the case of, say, flood, as an example, whereas there's some very cheap things that could be done, which Andrew has shared, particularly with bushfire, that doesn't cost very much, but can have a big impact. 

    I think we're in a really good place where a lot of people want to do stuff, both economically, because it would impact their insurance premium in a positive way, but also for the good of the community, but they don't necessarily know what to do. 

    So, there's an education piece there, and then there's also a piece about actually knowing at more the community and even property level, what should or what shouldn't be done. 

    So there's no point over capitalising on something that's not going to create a benefit. Better to spend money on things that will actually create a real – what we would call in our world – a return on investment, right?

    Andy McLean  13:13

    And that's again where the insurance industry contributes, because you can provide the evidence for what works, what is worth investing in and what isn't?

    Scott Hawkins  13:23

    If you think of the general insurers in Australia, I think they've done quite a good job of how to do some really simple things. If you think of some of the TV commercials you see: “About once a month, clean your gutters”. A really simple thing – costs nothing for most people and has a big impact in the case of fire or even torrential rain. So there's some really good things that can be done quickly and cheaply, whereas there's some other ones where you need community mitigation for that type of a risk, not individual household mitigation.

    Andy McLean  13:56

    Well, it's funny you mentioned community, because that was my next question. This is obviously something that can't be solved by a single household or a single government. Andrew, if you were to imagine what an ecosystem might look like if everyone was pulling in the right direction and contributing, I suppose my question is: who should be in that ecosystem? Who should be playing a part?

    Andrew Gissing  14:18

    Well, firstly, you need a risk-based approach. And so that's why I completely agree with what Scott said about the role of the insurance sector. 

    The insurance sector has a very mature view of natural hazard risk here in Australia and globally, and is able to share those expertise and data. It’s really useful for communities and governments to be able to benefit from, and ultimately then want a locally tailored approach to managing that risk.

    So what you might do in one community is going to be completely different in a different community, because the risk is different, and so investing in local government is really important. 

    One of the things here in Australia is that we've got some really high-risk areas, but in those areas we've got relatively low-capacity councils. And so investing in those councils that particularly have lower capacity is a really important opportunity to be able to uplift the capability to manage disasters. 

    Here, the other thing is the community. The community needs to have their say about how they're going to adapt to the future climate and mitigate these risks as well. I go to my own hometown of Wagga Wagga, in the suburb of North Wagga, there is a the, "We will not be moved”. So, when we think about things like assisted relocation into the future of some really severely impacted areas, communities need to buy into those as well. 

    Obviously, there needs to be funding partnerships as well, and a lot of disaster mitigation really is a money problem. There is a lot of solutions out there that can be deployed, but it's often councils and others competing for various grant funding to be able to implement these solutions to benefit their community. So, finding innovative ways to supplement government funding, I think is a really important thing that we need to be thinking more about in the future.

    Andy McLean  16:05

    You mentioned investing in local governments there. I just want to clarify, what does that really look like?

    Andrew Gissing  16:13

    Yeah, so that means tangible support for local councils to understand their risk, to develop plans that tailor mitigation, and implement risk reduction measures to that risk. And then a capability for them to obtain funding, as we've spoken about, a lot of time grant funding is used to fund disaster risk reduction investments, being able to apply for grants, being and manage those, the project managers, etc. That's really a bit of a package that we could be investing more in to support these local councils that don't have a lot of capacity.

    Andy McLean  16:48

    Andrew, we started to dig in here to communities and engaging communities and mobilising communities. I'm just sort of reflecting on how much communication with communities has changed in the past few years, and probably the area that dominates my thinking most there is social media. And that has become a complicating factor – and also potentially an empowering factor as well – for governments and other safety authorities who are trying to help communities and educate communities. How does social media complicate and also, potentially, help?

    Andrew Gissing  17:28

    Yeah, we've been doing some good research at Natural Hazards Research Australia with the University of Melbourne on this, looking at how communities have used social media post-Cyclone Alfred and also the May floods last year on the mid-north coast here in New South Wales. 

    So traditional media was often used to communicate both messages about risk and during emergencies and afterwards. But social media over the past decade and a half has really introduced a new way of engaging with communities – but also it created additional complexities. 

    Social media was used to be used by government agencies almost still as a broadcasting tool, similar to the way that you'd use traditional media to broadcast your message widely out through a network, but with the new approaches being used in social media, particularly these algorithmic approaches, which “reward” engagement in terms of how to extend the reach of messaging. 

    So there's a new way: we've obviously got influencers in the social media domain. We've got private companies that offer weather information in that domain there as well, which are widely followed. And it really challenges the way that traditional emergency warning and engagement occurs through social media. And that's not necessarily something that we've got strong answers to at the moment, but something that we're certainly challenging our emergency service colleagues, particularly about, is how they will take the research and information and use that more in the future? And perhaps about how they work more with influencers, for example, to get their messaging across – realising this whole dynamic, the complexity of social media, and how those messages are created and communicated and on forwarded and digested by communities at the end of the day to promote action.

    Andy McLean  19:19

    This is interesting, Scott, because if I was communicating messages to the people on this podcast, the two of you, I'd be talking in terms of “maths and risk”. I know Andrew's got a background in economics, so I'd be kind of making my case there, but actually, when we're talking to communities, we're talking about educating people in a way that engages them, right?

    Scott Hawkins  19:43

    Absolutely, and I think that starts with, as Andrew was saying, the form of communication. So, what's the form of communication that resonates with the community? And then it's making sure that the communication is delivered or given by an informed source, given the comments about social media. 

    And then in a language that actually the audience understands, and I think that's where the insurance industry is very good at talking in the language that we understand, and not necessarily the language that others understand.

    And the bug bear for me is return periods. So as someone with a strong mathematics background, that's really easy for me to understand, but if I explained that to my 11 year old and said that this is “a one in 50 year event”, then she would say, “Dad, that's not going to happen for another 49 years!”. 

    So it's about how we articulate our message in a way that lands with the audience, and then they can actually take away the message behind that and what they need to do.

    Andy McLean  20:39

    Scott, are you seeing signs that all these different parties are starting to come together, governments, but also banks and financiers, insurers, of course, and community agencies?

    Scott Hawkins  20:53

    So, I think the first step there is the Hazard Insurance Partnership has brought national emergency government and the insurance industry together, so that’s a really positive step in identifying the key catchments, and then what should maybe be prioritised going forward. So I think that's one step. 

    The thing that makes it complicated is that we do have three levels of government, and it's very hard to have one action that requires all three and get it done in a short enough period of time, so there's work to be done there. There's certainly dialogue at the various levels of government as to how that could make that happen going forward. 

    I think in terms of funding some of those things, what we really need is more of a top-down approach than a bottom-up approach. So historically, we've had individual small grants that individuals or communities could then apply for which may not actually give, if we think about it from an economic point of view, “bang for the buck” for the overall community. 

    So we really need to prioritise where we spend the money, and then also subsequently have a separate stream where we really look at where are the things that we think can't be mitigated or can't be done in a cost-effective manner, and we need to take the really hard decision that maybe we need to, well, first of all, clearly stop building there, and also relocate those people out of harm's way over a period of time. Historically, that's been really hard to do, and usually we've only done that after a natural disaster, as we've seen in New Zealand back in 2010–2011. What we need to do is be proactive and actually try and do some of this before the disaster happens.

    Andy McLean  22:27

    Andrew, do you feel optimistic that we will be able to make some of these step changes and transformational changes we've talked about today?

    Andrew Gissing  22:34

    I am feeling optimistic, but you know that optimistim varies in different parts of the problem. 

    Where I'm feeling really optimistic is around the technology side. What we're seeing over time in natural hazards here in Australia, and around the world, is we're able to bring in technologies, perhaps that are being used in different contexts, and bring them in to the natural hazards game, and really change the outcome. 

    So, when I think about early warning, for example, we've been able to reduce the death toll from natural hazards across the world because we're enhancing our early warning systems. And what's that about? That's enhanced telecommunications, being able to get warnings to people that have not been able to receive warnings before, and people are able to then make proactive measures to safeguard their homes, their families, etc. So that's an example. 

    When I look at things like fire tech for wildfire here in Australia, I see the ability now to detect fires a lot easier, which means that we're able to put them out quicker. We're seeing some amazing advances in fire modelling and decision support systems. 

    And then I see on the suppression side, which five years ago I probably was thinking it was some decades beyond where we are now. We're starting to see some really cool tech, like some drone swarms, et cetera, being applied and trialled into the suppression game. And you can see how autonomy will become really key thing over the decades to come in the in the bushfire fighting space. 

    In other areas, it's more traditional mitigations, right? That's really talking about, you know, levy building, relocation of homes, and again, I reckon that that challenge is again the financing of that. 

    You know, unfortunately, this all costs money, and governments - we know that here in Australia, fiscal constraints are high, and disaster risk reduction is competing against other parts of the budget. 

    I think the opportunity there, though, is to actually communicate the true cost of natural hazards. The insurance sector does a great job of communicating the insured cost, but we don't do a great job of communicating the true cost of natural hazards. 

    You know: what are all those intangible damages? What are all those infrastructure damages? What's the impact upon broader productivity? 

    We know that, for example, domestic and family violence goes up after disasters, and we know that there's all these other social costs. We need to have better ways of costing those. 

    We're doing some great research at the moment, looking at intangibles from floods, for example, and building out tools to better estimate the costs of extreme heat across the country. These are the sorts of tools that will be really necessary to convince decision makers about the true cost of hazards and what can be avoided by investing in disaster risk reduction.

    Scott Hawkins  25:18

    And I think, on top of that (Andrew makes excellent points there) the other one is, what's the true cost that's coming? So we currently look at the true insured cost largely. We can already look at what the overall cost is outside of just the insurance industry, but what we're not doing is saying that “if we do nothing or do what we currently do, what would that cost look like in 20 years?”. And I think that that also would inform a different economics about spending the money. It's then the return on the future investment, not the return on the investment directly today.

    Andrew Gissing  25:54

    And again, just to follow Scott's line of thinking there as well: think about a land use planning proposal. Being able to use things like “NatCat loss modelling” to say to government, “okay, if you invest in this over the next 50 years, the lifetime of the assets, this is what it's actually going to cost you to build here”. As opposed to, if you were to build over here, this is what the outcome would be, and this would be also the outcome for the broader market in terms of maintaining insured affordability, like for disaster reduction in Australia. 

    I think one of the best ways to actually engage with decision-makers is the cost-of-living argument. Insurance is such a big thing, which is touching mums and dads out there in terms of insurance pressures and cost-of-living pressures. If we can be reducing those through disaster risk reduction and show how that investment is influencing the broader cost-of-living pressure and debate in the country, then I think that's a not a bad way of framing things from a political perspective.

    Andy McLean  26:48

    Yeah, that's beautifully put, Andrew. That’s a message I think that will resonate  from Wagga Wagga to Canberra and beyond. 

    Well, today's conversation has rattled along, and Andrew, amazingly, that's all we've got time for. So, thank you so much for such a fascinating discussion today.

    Andrew Gissing  27:04

    Yeah, my pleasure for being here and sharing the important messages around disaster risk reduction.

    Andy McLean  27:09

    Yeah, it's been really enjoyable and very enlightening. Scott, perhaps we could wrap up with a final word from you. If there was one practical change that we could make to avoid locking in future risk, what would you like to see?

    Scott Hawkins  27:24

    Andy, the one change that I'd like to see is when we make decisions, we make them with a long-term perspective and thinking about the broad implications and not just the problem that we're trying to solve today.

    Andy McLean  27:35

    Yep, that's probably the running theme of this conversation, isn't it? Thinking about the broader implications, what's the bigger picture? And if we do that, we were going to make a more compelling case for the transformational change that we've been arguing for.

    Scott Hawkins  27:48

    Absolutely,

    Andy McLean  28:01

    Thanks for listening to this episode of Reinsurance Rendezvous, a podcast by Munich Re. 

    To find out more about the topics covered in this episode, check out Scott Hawkins' latest LinkedIn blog on the impact of climate change in Australia and how the insurance industry is rising to this. 

    To read that piece, just search for Scott Hawkins on LinkedIn, and to make sure you don't miss any of our forthcoming episodes, please subscribe to Reinsurance Rendezvous on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or indeed, wherever you get your podcasts. And while you're there, do feel free to leave us a rating or a review. We'd be very grateful if you did. 

    Until next time, this is me, Andy McLean, saying thanks so much for listening, and goodbye for now.

    Listen to more episodes of Reinsurance Rendezvous

    Learn more about extreme weather