Transforming Disaster Resilience: An Insurance Industry Perspective (S3E2)
Reinsurance Rendezvous podcast
About this episode
Building resilient communities that can adapt to the increasing frequency and severity of natural disasters has never been more relevant. Join this conversation to find out why there’s a need for a proactive approach to disaster resilience and mitigation not only within the insurance industry, but in partnership with community, government and private sectors.
Kate Cotter, CEO & Founder, the Resilient Building Council joins host Scott Hawkins to dive into this critical discussion that's dominating agendas in business and government everywhere.
Episode transcript
Audiograb:
“That's the moment when people are least able to do anything about future risk—they are in survival mode after disaster. It's also the time when local and state governments and everybody else that's involved with that disaster are most under stress. So it's not really the time for strategic work. So these programs need to be data informed. They need to be long-term. We need to get community and all the stakeholders buy in and planning long before disaster strikes.”
Andy:
Hello and welcome to Reinsurance Rendezvous, a podcast by Munich Re. I'm Andy McLean, a podcast producer based in Sydney. And joining me as always is Scott Hawkins, the Managing Director of Munich Re Australasia. Hello Scott.
Scott:
Hi, Andy. Great to be back.
Andy:
Well, Scott, as always in this episode, we're featuring you in conversation with a leading voice in the insurance industry. Who's your guest today?
Scott:
So Andy, today my guest is Kate Cotter, Kate's the founder and CEO of the Resilient Building Council. Prior to that, Kate established the Bushfire Building Council of Australia in 2014. That organisation focused purely on bushfire sharing the experience of resilience and sustainable buildings with a broader community. Using her expertise, Kate created great connections with experts in disaster resilience and sustainability, building collective partnerships across industry, government, and not for profits.
This great work led to the expansion of the Bushfire version to the Resilient Building Council in 2022.
Andy:
That's right. Kate's doing some really vital work and the need for it has never been more pressing. Her goal is to transform the way we approach disasters, shifting from a cycle of damage and repair to one of proactive, resilience, and preparedness. So in this conversation, the two of you explore some of the key challenges and opportunities in making our buildings and communities safer. A topic that's of major concern for communities, businesses, and governments locally and globally.
Scott, reflecting on the conversation, what were some of the things that stood out for you?
Scott:
We had a broad discussion about how to engage with communities when it comes to resilience, giving them tangible things they can do, which can give them real, tangible, and financial benefits. We also talked about how do we have a good mechanism for comparing different properties to actually see the different vulnerabilities and how do we use that information to really make big decisions about what to do with those risks going forward.
Basically saying, how do we best spend the money of the communities and the country?
Andy:
Sounds like you've covered quite a lot of ground in a short space of time, so we should probably jump in and take a listen.
Scott:
Hi Kate, welcome to the show.
Kate:
Thanks for having me.
Scott:
Kate, for the benefit of the listeners who don't know the Resilient Building Council, could you give a background as to where you came from and what sorts of work it is that you do?
Kate:
It's an organisation I founded back in 2014 and it was following the 2009 Black Saturday bushfires down in Victoria. So we came together to bring experts into the room and to try and translate science so that it's actionable by people. And our main focus is measuring how resilient buildings are so we can give people action plans and really clear information about what they can do to make their homes and businesses safer.
Scott:
So a big part of the work that my company does is really helping rebuild after those natural disasters. And if I look through my own business, the number of natural disasters is increasing, the scale and severity of those disasters is also increasing. So clearly this is a problem that we have to tackle. How can we use the great information that you have in your organisation to fix this going forward?
Kate:
We see ourselves as I guess the communicator. And we do that by measuring the performance of buildings and we provide that in a rating system. So our job really is to apply research and evidence so that it can be actioned by people. And I think what's important now considering escalating risks and escalating exposure to those risks is we have this great opportunity to do something about it and those actions need to be really practical.
So that's really our job is to not just say what the risks are, but what we do about it and then to create the value out of that so we can drive incentives and better building codes. And really everything comes from measurement. If we can measure it, we can do something about it.
Scott:
And therefore you would have a lot of community engagement. And I guess you often would hear questions like, so what can I do as an individual? What can the community do? How does that engagement model look like?
Kate:
We partner with community organisations to deliver programs directly into communities, and that can be post-disaster or, where most of our focus is, pre-disaster where we're trying to help people prepare so they don't have to go through those events. So the model is we take research and evidence, we turn it into systems and tools that people can use, and then we partner with community organisations, local governments, and others to then help people use these systems and tools both for their own homes and businesses and communities, but also to inform some of those bigger decisions.
So we measure that resilience both at that asset level, but also community and neighbourhood level, state and federal level as well. So those decisions and those investments are multi-layered. It's right down to individual people all the way up to where should Commonwealth money and state money be going into infrastructure and community level actions.
Scott:
And I guess it's there the tangible benefit that the community is looking for is how does that affect my insurance premium? How does that affect my access to banking capital to actually buy properties?
Kate:
That's exactly right. And we're seeing those adverse outcomes play out now. So from the Actuaries Institute report last August, 15% of Australian households can't access affordable insurance. So that number's gone up by 30% since the year before. That's telling us that market failure risks are there, and it's not just statistical. It's what we see on the ground where people can't afford insurance. They are essentially carrying all of that risk themselves.
All of their wealth is tied up in their property, particularly in Australia, that's where all our wealth is. So for those families who are in high risk areas, potentially in an old building, but some newer buildings are high risk too. They can't do anything. They're stuck, they're very difficult to sell, they can't refinance, they can't get insurance. So that's market failure playing out on the ground, and that is only going in one direction. It's going up.
So the interventions must happen now. We have to help people get out of this situation. And I think those systemic financial risks will affect, and they do affect all of us. All of our premiums are going up. All of the banks are going to have higher costs of capital. It's going to affect everybody, and it already is. So it's not an isolated problem. It's something we need to deal with in those particular high risk areas, but it affects every system for every person.
Scott:
I mean, some of the work that I've been involved with also through the insurance council has really been looking at where are the high risk properties and also putting a socioeconomic overlay on that. And what you find quite rightly is that the way the housing stock industry is, a lot of the most exposed properties are in the lower socioeconomic areas where they can't afford to do the resilience work themselves.
They also can't afford the premiums. And that's why we then see under insurance and no insurance. It feels like that's a great intersection for a public-private partnership where you would bring governments in to take or assist with some of those. Is that work that you are seeing?
Kate:
Absolutely. That's central to actually helping the people that need the most help. So public capital has got a very important role here to help high-risk areas adapt and to provide capital where there isn't the financial capacity. And we also try and bring in those market mechanisms to help people who've got the financial capacity. So those two things in harmony, exactly what you're saying, a public-private partnership is how we have equity in resilience, and that's incredibly important.
And we also want public capital to be used in the most efficient and effective way. And that's where I think the work through the Hazards Insurance Partnership and the work that we are doing, state and territories and banks. We've all got a role that can help support that two-pronged approach, which is market solutions and very targeted, effective public capital where it's most needed.
Scott:
And we've seen through previous research that money spent pre-disasters is much better spent than post-disasters and has the biggest impact. I think it's really important when we've talked so far about really the current building stock, but I guess it would be true that what we're doing there is also very applicable to future building stock and where we should be building going forward.
Kate:
That's exactly right. And that is the moment that has the lowest incremental cost for building in resilience. So if you make really good land use planning decisions and we show people how to build to best practice and make that really affordable in the new building design stage, we save an enormous amount further down the road. It might cost a couple of thousand dollars to lift resilience beyond minimum standards in a new build compared to 30, 40, $50,000 for an older building.
So it's a very smart thing to do to really target doing things better now. And we want buildings to last generations. So that means we've got to design them and build them in the right places in the right way today, as well as trying to deal with all those past mistakes. And if we've got, say, 11 million dwellings in Australia, at least half of those need some resilience work to be able to be fit for purpose.
Scott:
And if I extend that even further, it feels like the other... And it's probably the toughest decision we need to make is what building stock shouldn't really be there anymore. So to actually inform through the work of your organisation and others, what of those properties actually should be bought back and potentially those individuals or even communities moved to a longer term more sustainable environment?
Kate:
Well, we have a good understanding of that now in that we measure residual risks. So where we can't lift someone's rating from where it is today through a retrofit or a raise or changing the risk through land management or other methods to bring that risk down. Where we can't move the dial that tells us that we need another plan. So that's where that data is really important and we measure that.
So I think that's a really good input that might help government understand where that risk actually can't be adjusted through adaptation of the buildings or other methods of bringing down that risk. And that's where you want to start having the retreat conversation. It's where we might look at more community-level infrastructure and every community is so different that that will be a different mix of solutions that will help to bring down that risk and access insurance for those communities.
Scott:
So as an Australian, we love to compare things. We compare our house to our neighbor's house, we love to compare everything. So your rating system is a great way to compare resilience. How would you see that rating system being used more broadly in the financial community?
Kate:
That's the system we've built and it's taken a decade of work, and we're only getting it out now, but the Resilience Ratings program is there for a number of reasons. One is it helps people know how effective particular actions will be so they can measure it. It's also to help with disclosure so that when we sell properties, people should have that information about how resilient that property is before they buy. But it's also the mechanism that can provide some of those market solutions.
So having that consistent rating system helps insurers price the risk reduction and banks, but it also helps investors. So it's a fantastic lever for us to demonstrate as Australia moves the dial and can aggregate all of those individual actions and say, "We are actually reducing risk here, we are adapting. We can then measure that and provide that to markets." And that means we become a very attractive place to invest in and bringing that lower cost of capital in filters all the way down to consumers.
And that has worked for emissions reduction and green bonds and other ways of demonstrating to investors through a measurement, through a rating that action has been taken. It can be valued and priced and rewarded.
Scott:
I mean, it really feels like the first step really needs to be a good foundational data set that can then be used by multiple parties for multiple purposes. How would you see that working?
Kate:
I think that's a great role for the Commonwealth to lead on. I think they've got that ability to bring all of those parties together and then also to disseminate that information nationally. And we know that when that's done well, it drives innovation and solutions. So we need both of those things to happen. We need to provide a good base for everybody to start inventing solutions from. And we also need to stimulate that investment in innovative solutions and make that part of how Australia does its future made in Australia program.
We've got to bring adaptation and resilience into these huge national programs. Our climate action needs to have both sides of the climate coin, both our emissions' reduction, which is essential, and also our resilience and adaptation. So there's some great levers that could be pulled if we think of things in a more holistic way. And a lot of those levers are already there. Net-zero, future made in Australia, our sustainable finance taxonomies. All of this great work and having a great national data set and also investing in our corporations and startups that can actually provide great solutions for resilience and adaptation.
We've got the foundation for that if we just expand our thinking a bit and include resilience and adaptation in our policies and funding and programs.
Scott:
So it feels like if I summarised our discussion, it's very much we need a good data set to drive decisions. We need good community engagement so people know what they can do or what they can't do. We also need a real intersection and let's call it a public-private partnership, to say, what's the best funding mechanism to make the biggest impact? And how do we best use that money? So pre-losses and disasters rather than post-losses and disasters.
If I try and take that forward a little bit further, I'd say based on that, we can then make a decision. Is it something that the individual can do themselves? Is it something that we then can do at a community level? Or is there actually a harder decision to be made for some properties to say, "Based on this information, actually buying those properties back is the best option."
Kate:
Exactly. And without that information, we can't make informed decisions. And what often happens is that we make knee-jerk reactions often after disaster. And that's the moment when people are least able to do anything about future risk. They are in survival mode. It's also the time when local and state governments and everybody else that's involved with that disaster are most under stress. So it's not really the time for strategic work.
So I think these programs need to be data informed. They need to be long-term. We need to get community and all the stakeholders buy in and planning long before disaster strikes. So if we can shift that mindset to reactionary, to strategic and well-planned, the outcomes I think will be far better.
Scott:
I think, Kate, that's a hundred percent right. And to maybe finish off today, I think as we've had many topics on this podcast and we've come back to the same sort of rationale, we need things to be informed by good quality data that everyone has access to. We need to ensure that we actually work as a system together.
And in the end, I think we need to make sure we're doing the right thing for the communities and for the people who are affected. So to finish up, Kate, is there anything else that would be your ask of any part of the ecosystem?
Kate:
I think you've hit the nail on the head in terms of data, transparency, and also bringing existing programs for climate action into resilience and adaptation. So it's really not about reinventing the wheel, it's using all of the things that we know work and work in other arenas and applying it to this problem. And I think really our main message is if we empower people, whether it's households, or businesses, or industry. Empowerment drives solutions and innovation and it brings down costs.
So I think that would be our central theme. If we put the power into people's hands, and if we stimulate industry innovation, we can lead the world here. We've got a fantastic opportunity.
Scott:
I think that's a great ambition for all of us to have. Thanks for joining me today, Kate.
Kate:
Thanks, Scott.
Andy:
That was Kate Cotter, the founder and CEO of the Resilient Building Council in conversation with Scott Hawkins, the managing director of Munich Re Australasia. Thank you for listening to this episode of Reinsurance Rendezvous, a podcast by Munich Re. To find out more about the topics covered in this episode, check out Scott Hawkins recent LinkedIn article about disaster recovery and mitigation. To read that piece, search for Scott Hawkins on LinkedIn.
And to make sure you don't miss any of our future episodes, please subscribe to Reinsurance Rendezvous on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or indeed wherever you get your podcasts. And while you're there, feel free to leave us a rating or a review. Until next time, thanks so much for listening, and goodbye for now.