© [M] Munich Re [P1] AlexSecret / Getty Images - AI-modified

Evolving Cyber Risk Landscape (S2E3)

Reinsurance Rendezvous podcast

    Track image

    0:00
    0:00
    By pressing the start button, Liberated Syndication Inc. (“Libsyn”) will process personal data about your use of the player. More information can be found in Libsyn’s privacy notice.

    Listen and subscribe on: Spotify | Apple

    About this episode

    The cyber risk landscape is rapidly changing. How do we provide the cover for this newly evolving risk?

    Join the conversation as host Scott Hawkins, MD of Munich Re Australasia and special guest Stefan Golling, Member of the Board of Management, Munich Re Group reveal how the insurance industry is leaning into the world of cyber risk. They explore the driving forces behind the increasing need for cyber insurance; the necessary skills and data needed to keep up with evolving technologies and risks; and ask what's simply too big or too systemic to cover? Get ready to listen to this critical discussion that's dominating agendas in business and government everywhere.

    Stefan, Scott (00:03): 

    Intro extract:

    So therefore it was, I think a big challenge at that time to say, are we as an insurance industry shying away from that risk or are we developing something to support our end customers, to support our reinsurance clients? And I'm glad that we did decide I think for the right one.

    And I think Stefan, that's a really good point where in sort of my career, I'd say cyber is probably one of the first ones where instead of excluding coverage, the industry leant into the topic to say how do we actually give the cover?

    Andy (00:41):

    Hello and welcome to Reinsurance Rendezvous, a podcast by Munich Re. My name's Andy McLean. I'm a podcast producer based in Sydney. And joining me as always is Scott Hawkins, the managing director of Munich Re Australasia. Hello again, Scott.

    Scott (00:56):

    Hi Andy.

    Andy (00:47):

    So Scott, as always in this episode, we are featuring you in conversation with a leading voice in the insurance industry. Who's your guest today?

    Scott (01:06):

    So today my guest is an old colleague and friend, Stefan Golling. Stefan's, a member of the Board of Management of Munich Re. Stefan's got over two decades of experience primarily in underwriting roles across several continents.

    Andy (01:19):

    And obviously Stefan's got a wide range of expertise and knowledge, but in this particular conversation, you two drill down into one of the fastest growing and fastest changing risks in the world right now, which is cyber. It's a topic that's dominating agendas in business and governments everywhere. So tell us a little bit about what the two of you cover in your discussion.

    Scott (01:41):

    The conversation today, we focused on a few things. We focused on what's driving the increased need for cyber insurance when we think about digitalization and connectivity. We talked about what are the skills and expertise that we need to bring into our industry to make sure that we can cope and manage and actually create products that solve these problems for our clients. We also spoke about what are the things that simply are too big or too systemic to cover in this product? And then lastly, we talked about who else needs to help us to be able to have enough capacity to provide the product for those who need it.

    Andy (02:1):

    Wow, there's a lot to unpack there isn't there? And you covered a lot of ground in a short space of time. So without further ado, let's jump in and hear the conversation.

    Scott (02:2):

    So Stefan, welcome to the podcast.

    Stefan (02:27):

    Hello Scott. Thanks for having me back. But Scott, I also need to tell you, if I'm honest, I would've preferred to have an invite in person to Sydney. Would've been much nicer to engage with you personally with many of the industry friends that I think still have. But being with you today virtually is better than nothing.

    Scott (02:42):

    Better than nothing. And maybe we'll do a part two on this or another topic and we'll do that one in person. How does that sound?

    Stefan (02:48):

    That sounds good to me.

    Scott (02:50):

    Perfect. Well, Stefan, today we're here to talk about cyber. I've been reflecting recently about increases in technology, what that means for interconnectedness of businesses, and of course the additional risks that come from this increase in technology when we think about cyber attacks, loss of data, system outages. So how would you see the impact on businesses and insurance and therefore the need for cyber insurance compared to the past?

    Stefan (03:18):

    Yeah, very valid point. When I think back 10 years ago when I left you and the Australia market, I had no expectation that now 10 years later I would sit with you on a podcast and talking about cyber. And if you had said, we talk again about maybe some quake explosion in New Zealand, some wildfires, whatever, some floods in Australia, then I would've said, yeah, let's do this. But when I came back to Munich 10 years ago, becoming the chief underwriter of Munich Re, I quickly realised you don't need to think about the day-to-day business only, but you think about what is kind of affecting the industry over the next five, 10 years. And already that time I think it was clear that all these developments that you mentioned, technological development, digitalization, people talking about big data, people talking about the internet of things, that this somehow will affect the risk landscape, not only the risk landscape for us as the reinsurers, but also for our reinsurance clients and maybe most importantly for their customers.

    (04:21):

    So I think it was clear that cyber risk is not only a big risk out there, but this technology, there are lots of opportunities. And of course with opportunities, there's always a role for the insurance industry because usually opportunities can only be realised if people also know that someone covers the risk. So therefore it was, I think a big challenge at that time to say, are we as an insurance industry shying away from that risk or are we developing something to support our end customers, to support our reinsurance clients? And I'm glad that we did decide I think for the right one.

    Scott (04:56):

    And I think Stefan, that's a really good point where in sort of my career, I'd say cyber is probably one of the first ones where instead of excluding coverage, the industry leant into the topic to say how do we actually give the cover? And I think that's a real win for the insurance industry. And then also goes to things like closing insurance gaps. For many years we've talked about the insurance gap in terms of pricing and availability of natural perils type cover. We now need to talk about that same insurance gap when it comes to cyber coverage where we can see a lack of penetration in many markets. How are we thinking about how we work to close that gap as an industry, not just as a reinsurer?

    Stefan (05:40):

    Yeah, so first of all, I think you're right, in nat cat we talk about maybe insurance densities of 30, 40%, and in cyber, I guess it's less than 5%, maybe it's even less than 1%. When you think about the huge economic losses that we can see out there and the actual size of the cyber insurance market, excluding it would've been the very easy answer, I think. And let's be honest, 10 years ago and even maybe now, there are still voices out there that say cyber is not insurable. Is it insurable or not insurable? First of all, because of course we don't have 100 years of historical data. We don't have the same experience as we have in NatCat, in fire, in motor insurance. But of course also because of that huge accumulation potential. There is not this geographical diversification that we have in NatCat or there is not this diversification between different lines of businesses. But there were two reasons why we said we need to make it insurable.

    (06:38):

    I think by not covering that risk, I think the insurance industry would've faced an even bigger risk, and risk of becoming irrelevant to our customers. We need to find solutions for the problems that worry our customers. And the other alternative, not developing then a firm risk appetite and affirmative products, but have presumably meant that we have to cover it for free and our traditional products one day we'll face a big surprise. So therefore it was really crucially important to develop a risk appetite to start collecting data, to invest in cyber expertise and then also to develop some affirmative coverages to work together across the entire industry. I think that was for us, very important right from the beginning.

    (07:2):

    I think we always said we shouldn't fool ourselves. We can't understand cyber better ourselves alone than if we were to work together with the entire industry, working together with our insurance partners, working together with our broking partners, but also working together with new partners in the cyber ecosystem. So with big tech companies, which insure techs was also the start of many of the insure tech companies about 10 years ago with startups in the cyber security space and so on. And by bringing all that cyber security expertise, the insurance expertise together, working on accumulation models, at the end we were able to come up with products that hopefully will also serve the need of our customers.

    Scott (08:1):

    And I think that's a really good point you embraced there, Stefan, in terms of new skills and new experiences. I think traditionally as an industry we very much leveraged what we already knew to expand into new products. And here's a great example of actually bringing in a new product where we weren't the experts. From your perspective, what are the sorts of skills and experience that we need to bring into the industry to keep abreast of what's happening in cyber and so we can keep up to date with the ever-evolving technologies and the risks that we're covering?

    Stefan (08:43):

    I think it's exactly those skills that we see out in the market that develop exactly these new technologies that lead all the transformation in our industry that talk about AI and develop AI, that talk about cyber security and developers. So it's really about combining the deep domain expertise in cyber security as well as the underwriting expertise. I think it's also not possible to come up with a cyber insurance product if you just understand the cyber product. At the end, you also need to understand the insurance business, the insurance market. You need to understand how to draft the policy.

    (09:18):

    Maybe most importantly at the beginning, you need to also know how to sell a product. In various markets, we had a product but we weren't good in selling it. We as a reinsurance maybe anyway, not the best owner for distribution of driving the sales, but our clients, our broking partners, underwriting agencies and so on, they also had to first develop the skills to actually convince customers that there's value in such a product. And also to educate the customers when a cyber insurance policy will respond and when not.

    Scott (09:49):

    And Stefan, I think particularly one of the markets that you're very familiar with these days in North America, I think the penetration of cyber is a lot higher than it is in say, Australia. So Australia is trying to catch up fast. I think one of the issues we've had is to that very point, trying to sell the product and to show exactly what the coverage is that people are buying. And I think there's certainly some work to be done, but I think it's also about how to better articulate the services that we have around cyber. So it's not just the insurance, it's the knowledge of the protection that the company has and also how to react post an event. Is that something which you're then seeing in other markets as an area to further develop?

    Stefan (10:30):

    Absolutely. I think there's a couple of triggers for why maybe some markets are already more advanced in cyber insurance. First of all, I think it starts also with regulation or with privacy laws for example. So I think in the yes, these were the front-runners of introducing some privacy laws and some data protection laws and so on. So where we suddenly also saw the benefit of having a cyber product. Then also of course regulation in respect of what do we expect actually from board of directors running companies. In the past, for sure, they thought about do we have sprinklers and do we buy fire policies? But I think there is no boardroom discussion anymore without talking about the cybersecurity of its own business and how to respond to a data breach, how to deal with regulators, how to deal with business interruption and so on. So these triggers, these external triggers, I would say unfortunate thing in the market that helped in some markets the cyber insurance to fly.

    (11:33):

    There was a soft market also in some markets from 14 to 18, and thereby insurance buyers maybe had some money left to play around with. So they really said, okay, if I can save five or 10% of my fire policy, maybe it's worth spending, not saving this, but spending this, experimenting this with cyber insurance that helped actually some markets also to develop it. But the selling point of view and also not only selling the insurance policy, but providing additional services around basically cybersecurity standards about incident response services and so on, is a really crucial component. It's actually always a good one for the insurance industry because that makes the busy much more sticky. If you do not only interact with your customer every five years after claim, but if you actually can demonstrate that you can bring value to your customer and ongoing monitoring of their risk by an immediate reaction, then there's not even insured loss yet, but just an incident and so on. So I think these are very good factors to help the overall cyber insurance markets to develop.

    Scott (12:39):

    Absolutely. And Stefan, as we talk about how to sell a product, it's about being clear what is covered. But I guess equally important, it's also to be clear about what's not covered in a policy. And certainly if we think about the traditional insurances that we've done for 300 years, there's certain things that we say are so systemic that there's no diversification, that we simply can't cover it. If we think about some forms of nuclear terrorism, other nuclear type events, war. Of course when we think of cyber, it is systemic. There is no global diversification. So there's clearly some things that we can't cover. So from your perspective, what are the things that we can't cover? And if it's purely because of the size is too big, how do we get others to enter the market to also be able to better protect some of those risks?

    Stefan (13:29):

    Yeah, I think having transparency in coverage there also transparency in where are the limitations of the coverage possible. So the limitations of our risk appetite is absolutely important. And if we haven't learned something from COVID and all the discussions around what is covered under the traditional policy when it comes to, for example, pandemic risk and so on, then we should not even maybe start to think about further developing the cyber market. So having this transparency, this clear coverage in wordings is absolutely clear. And when it comes to accumulation, then I think we currently see very good examples in the market. We recently had this crowd strike incident whereby one problem, several businesses around the world were impacted. So we had a large scale, basically, outage or problem at an IT service provider, and it had impact on businesses for many, many of our customers. This is something that we can cover and that we are willing to cover and it will be covered.

    (14:30):

    And fortunately overall now as far as we know, the event didn't turn out to be as bad as maybe some feared initially one or two days after the event occurred. But as you said, there are other events where we clearly see that the potential accumulation is maybe as big as in the global pandemic. We specifically addressed the two problems. First of all, the issue of failure of critical infrastructure. So when you think about, for example, power coming down or when you think about the telecommunication system not working anymore, then the sheer accumulation of affected customers in the entire world or in an entire region is by far too big. And the business interruption losses from that simply are not manageable by the private insurance industry.

    (15:15):

    The other topic that is also at the moment, very top on the agenda is the topic of cyber war. No one would argue that you could cover or not cover actually a traditional war scenario on the property policies. We all know that we can cover local events, regional events on the NatCat side where we also have accumulations, but to potentially cover all the losses from a physical war on the property policies has never been questioned. And it's the same thing on the cyber side. We cannot cover a cyber war because the potential accumulation is by far too big.

    (15:54):

    Of course, we can help develop solutions. We very often talk about private-public partnerships that we need to develop some coverage solutions together with our governments, local governments, but maybe even going beyond local government schemes. But we also need to be honest, that's a very long way. We discussed this I think after the pandemics, whether we shouldn't come up with some solutions there together with our politicians. And we need to be honest, the progress wasn't huge. So we should not make the mistake and say until we have developed something together with governments, we can cover it in the private insurance industry. No, we cannot. And at the same time, we still need to work together and maybe potentially coming up someday with private-public solutions.

    Scott (16:38):

    And I think Stefan, there's the point that sometimes people don't understand is the scale of the losses, not just from cyber but in other losses. Pandemic is a great example. If I think of Australia, there were questions as to could the insurance industry come up with a solution for the next pandemic? And if I think about the stimulus the Australian government put into the economy in the pandemic, it was more than the capitalisation of the insurance and re-insurance industry. So there are some things which simply the balance sheets of the industry can't cover.

    Stefan (17:10):

    So now that I'm responsible for the US market, I think we also did a study there. So just a couple of days of the potential business interruption losses caused by COVID would've been enough to simply exhaust the entire capital, not only of the U.S. insurance industry, but the worldwide insurance industry. And let's be honest, there is no help to our end customers if after  a big event insurance is not there anymore. So we need to provide coverage that also can be there after an event and therefore we should not shy away in defining the risk appetite and also clearly articulating to our customers, to our re-insurance clients, but also to the end customers where the private industry cannot offer solutions.

    Scott (17:53):

    I think that's an excellent point, Stefan. And if I think about the growing need for cyber, we have a varied risk appetite in the market at the moment. So from your perspective, what do you think the industry needs to do to encourage more capital, be it within the insurance industry or external to the insurance industry, to start to support the cyber risks that the entire world faces?

    Stefan (18:17):

    We said it at the beginning that the insurance penetration is presumably less than 5%, maybe even less than 1%. And when you think about the current cyber market, it's around I think between 15 and 20 billion now, maybe, let's call it 16, 17 billion. Then it's obvious that when we worry today already about the accumulation, then one day maybe we'll also reach our limits. But we are by far not there yet. At the moment it's still dominated by very few large players, a few primary insurance companies, and a handful of re-insurance companies. Munich Re at the moment has a market share, I think of between 15 and 10% in the entire cyber insurance market. That is so much more than what we would have in the property market or in the liability market. So I think the first thing is that we really need to increase the risk appetite within the entire insurance and re-insurance world.

    (19:10):

    So it can't be that cyber risks are only assumed by whatever, two dozen of leading primary insurance companies in five to 10 re-insurance companies, all the players in the insurance market have to lean and engage. What do we need for this? We need more confidence, I think, in our capabilities. So we need to be a bit more outspoken also about how we model this, how we control these accumulations, how coverages are responding, how they are defined. We need to articulate this also with the regulators, with investors so that overall there's more confidence. We at the moment try also to actively develop a retro market or an interest by the ILS market. But there also, again, we need to be realistic. After how many years, at the moment, there's still only an appetite for peak parallel cut risk in the ILS market. So we should not be naive that tomorrow the ILS market will provide the solution. There will only be a complement to the traditional insurance and re-insurance capital. So we should first I think, look to ourselves to develop the market.

    Scott (20:14):

    So I think Stefan, if I summarise our discussion, what we're really saying is it's a great example of probably one of the first times that as an industry we've really leant into a new risk. It's a new risk that definitely is evolving. Of course it brings with it the challenge of the insurance gap and that we really need to try and close that gap. And to do that, we need more capital and capacity to flow in to protect these exposures.

    (20:40):

    I think also what's important that people take away from our discussion is there is of course some things we simply can't cover. And there's some things that are so big that the balance sheet of the industry or even for some countries are unable to absorb those risks. And I think the other one is we need to attract talent into our industry that is knowledgeable about these risks and maybe it's a different type of role than they've had in the past in terms of working for an insurance company. So from your perspective, what are the other things that you think we need to think about as an industry to create an environment where people have an available sustainable product that can protect them from the cyber exposures that they now all face?

    Stefan (21:21):

    Yes, Scott, I think there are four themes that important for developing not only a sustainable cyber insurance market, but also a sustainable solution for our customers. So the first topic is really focusing on this, increasing the cyber expertise. We started this 10 years ago that we brought in the cyber expertise to complement the underwriting expertise, but we cannot stop here. We need to have this multidisciplinary approach with lots of different domain expertise to at the end manage this ever-changing risk environment and to also come up with some solutions for better risk prevention on the cyber security side for our customers. The second really important topic is data. Data is always important for the insurance world. And we have 100 years of data on fire, on motor, on natural catastrophes, but we don't have this yet on cyber. So we need to increase the quantity and also the quality of data on exposures, on trends, on losses, on incidents. Only then we will be able to better understand the risk, to underwrite the risks, and at the end also to model the accumulation.

    (22:28):

    And accumulation topic is the third one. We need to understand the systemic risk. We need to be able to differentiate between those accumulations that we can ensure, that we can control, that we can model and those that we cannot. Therefore, for example, the exclusion of cyber war was a really important step to make the cyber market sustainable.

    (22:49):

    And the fourth ingredient is we really need to think about developing sustainable capacity. If we have capacity for tomorrow, but after the next surprise event, we all shy away from this, it doesn't help us and it doesn't help our customers. So we really need to come up with a clearly defined risk appetite for ourselves. We need to come up with clear wordings with a transparent approach. And also we need to continuously work on increasing the cyber security standards on the client side. So these four topics, investing into the cyber expertise, into data, modelling systemic risk, and developing sustainable capacity will help us at the end to facilitate the development of a interesting cyber insurance market in the long run.

    Scott (23:34):

    Thanks, Stefan. So I think in closing, we have a real opportunity here to close a protection gap for a new and emerging risk, and that we have the willingness and the ability as an industry, what we need is some others to get on board with us to also make this happen. Thanks for your time today.

    Stefan (23:50):

    More than welcome. See you soon. Bye.

    Andy (23:56):

    That was Stefan Golling, a member of Board Management at Munich RE in Germany, in conversation with Scott Hawkins, the managing director of Munich Re Australasia. Thanks so much for listening to this episode of Reinsurance Rendezvous, a podcast by Munich Re. To find out more about the topics covered in this episode, check out Scott Hawkins' recent LinkedIn blog about cyber. To read that piece, search for Scott Hawkins on LinkedIn. And to make sure you don't miss any of our future episodes, including a special bonus episode on heart health featuring former yellow Wiggle Greg Page no less, please subscribe to Reinsurance Rendezvous on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. And while you're there, feel free to leave us a rating or a review. Until next time, thanks so much for listening and goodbye for now.

    Listen to more episodes of Reinsurance Rendezvous

    This may interest you