© [M] Munich Re [P1] AlexSecret / Getty Images - AI-modified

Bushfire (S2E2.2)

Reinsurance Rendezvous podcast

    Track image

    0:00
    0:00
    By pressing the start button, Liberated Syndication Inc. (“Libsyn”) will process personal data about your use of the player. More information can be found in Libsyn’s privacy notice.

    Listen and subscribe on: Spotify | Apple

    About this episode

    The reinsurance and insurance industry plays a central role in progressing bushfire mitigation efforts to the benefit of communities, governments and business alike. In this episode, we take a deep dive into the ways we can better address bushfire mitigation and foster future-focused sustainable practices rather than investing the primary efforts – and funds - into recovery activities.

    Both parts 1 and 2 of episode 2 are motivating conversations, with host Scott Hawkins, MD of Munich Re Australasia joined by special guest Professor David Bowman from the Transdisciplinary Fire Centre, University of Tasmania.

    Part 2

    Andy (00:05):

    Hello, and welcome to Reinsurance Rendezvous, a podcast by Munich Re. My name's Andy McLean. I'm a podcast producer based in Sydney, Australia. And joining me, once again, is Scott Hawkins, the managing director of Munich Re Australasia. Hello again, Scott.

    Scott (00:21):

    Hi Andy.

    Andy (00:22):

    Well, Scott, in this episode, we're sharing part two of your conversation with David Bowman, who's a hugely respected leader in wildfire science and management from the transdisciplinary Fire Centre at the University of Tasmania. Now, there was so much great material from your original conversation that we've split it into two parts. So when it comes to bushfires in Australia, there's a huge amount that we need to discuss. We've witnessed firsthand in Australia the devastation that comes from extreme weather events. So Scott, perhaps give us a little bit of a taster of what you and David cover in this part two of the discussion.

    Scott (01:01):

    In this discussion, we focused on the economics and when I say that, I mean, what are the barriers or the incentives that could make or break our efforts in adapting to fire risk. We focused on how the insurance industry will play a role or could play a role to further this development going forward. We looked at what are the kinds of investment that would be required for Australia to better mitigate and manage faster, this risk which is upon us and then lastly, how can we do this as a collective? How do we bring together the insurance industry, governments, and their agencies as well as the community to move us forward?

    Andy (01:39):

    Yeah, love that sentiment. This is all about all these different parties coming together to solve a common shared problem, isn't it? So let's jump in and hear the conversation.

    Scott (01:54):

    Hi David, welcome back to the Reinsurance Rendezvous podcast. Thanks for being here.

    David (01:59):

    Yeah, thanks, Scott.

    Scott (02:01):

    In part two, I'd like to kick off by talking about the economic barriers and incentives that could make or break our efforts to adapt to fire risk. What do you see as the most pressing economic issues?

    David (02:17):

    So these are very interesting questions. And believe it or not, this sort of more economic analysis that we need to do, hasn't been done in any systematic way. I've recently reviewed a paper, for instance, really cutting edge stuff, looking at using economic choice experiments to try to understand at the bottom at the community level, what are you willing to pay for and what are you wanting these benefits for? Are they environmental benefits or benefits for your community or to save house loss? But on the other side, which we can do because we have reasonably good models of fire risk, is that we could start exploring, economically, the benefit of these major interventions.

    (03:09):

    So they'd say, "Well, David, you mentioned this green halo and all of these irrigated trees and marsupial lawns and all of this, and you know integrated with golf courses and parklands and community gardens, well, what's the likely benefit? you know How would that actually, realistically, change fire behaviour or save housing stock? We know how to do that sort of work, but we haven't done it in any systematic way. And that's where some partnerships with insurers would be really interesting because you know what I like about the idea of insurance is that it's evidence-based, it's done on numbers. I imagine there's a bit of gut feeling in there, but it's still gut feeling around numbers and evidence, not just aspirational. 

    Scott (04:02):

    Right. So you're emphasising here, there really needs to be a clearer funding model, both for firefighting as well as for fire prevention.

    David (04:11):

    Everybody talks about the productivity commission number, which is, you know it's 93% or something is spent on fighting fires and 7% is spent on you know trying to mitigate their effect. So this goes back to better transparency of the cost of firefighting. And a really smart thing to do would be to have a gearing, and I think actually, you need to separate the firefighting agencies from the fuel management agencies because it all becomes lost in one, probably give them their own legislation. So we need a price signal, which is, well, you just blew X million dollars on fighting all these fires. 

    (04:53):

    That's bad and as a consequence, you have to give the other mob even more money to treat fuel. You know at the moment, it's like, oh, well, we'd love to treat more fuel, but we spent all our money on firefighting, and by the way, we need bigger aircraft. And everybody's cheering these bigger aircraft. They're not understanding that one airdrop is probably the equivalent of a really intensive community intervention that would be reducing fire hazard, you've only got to think about it for a minute, you know how much these aircraft cost, and it's not just you know the aircraft and the rental. You need ground crews, you need mixing agents, you need chemicals.

    (05:36):

    It's a whole economy in itself and they've got a very effective advocates, and we need more effective advocates saying, "For every dollar we spent fighting a fire, we should be spending a dollar managing fuel because that's the only way we're going to break out of this death cycle." There is this other bizarre thing, which they can be the victim of success too, that communities become complacent because they say, "Yeah, but last time there was a fire, they went and did an airdrop and put it out. So why should I do anything? because somebody will just go and put my fire out. I don't need to prepare."

    (06:12):

    And that's called the fire suppression paradox. And so we need to be thinking about incentivizing behaviour and having some sort of awareness that using that firefighting capacity. It's not a sustainable approach. I think the people who fight fires and doing all the stuff, they're amazing human beings, they're incredibly brave. We'd be lost without them. And the counterfactual probably doesn't bear thinking about we didn't have them. We've got to switch into a more sustainable approach. 

    Scott (06:47):

    And I think that brings us back to this shared or collective responsibility. So it really needs to be a collective of individuals, communities, governments, corporations. The question I'd have for you, David is, what would the silver bullet for your work be from the insurance industry? What would you need from the insurance industry to really bring this forward?

    David (07:07):

    The thing the insurance industry can provide, is that we need to incentivize changed behaviour. So we reward good behaviour. Now the challenge is, what's good behaviour? So we also have to have more research and development, and that's got to be concurrent, we know enough that there are good garden designs, there are bad garden designs, they're good houses, there are bad housing designs, you know  there are benefits in having bunkers and sprays, but they're not they’re not going to eliminate the risk, but they are going to make a substantial contribution, just as much as fuel management, fuel treatment, irrigation.

    (07:46):

    So what I would think, one of the things the insurance industry could do or government and the insurance industries should do, is to pick a couple of places where you'd do a really major intervention to demonstrate that it is possible to do this stuff. Now consider just switching your mind to another natural hazards, tropical cyclones. I lived in Darwin for a long time, and in Darwin, nobody thought anything about having a cyclone shelter. That was just normal. Of course you would have a cyclone shelter. Now obviously with time, you know  people are concerned about the building and you know where people are siting houses and some of the giant buildings that are being built. But by and large, there is an amazing achievement that came out of Cyclone Tracy, where people are focusing on a significant local natural hazard. 

    Scott (08:47):

    So David, could you give us an example of what you have in mind? When it comes to bushfires, how is it that insurers might be able to help?

    David (08:54):

    One of the things the insurance industry could do is choose a place, for instance, like Hobart, but it could be the Blue Mountains. It could be another place and say, "We want to actually do an experiment and we want to work with local government, we want to work with state government, we want to work with federal government." And it's not just you know a good time is had by all. We really want to demonstrate the sorts of necessary changes, administrative structural incentives.

    (09:26):

    I've been talking to the local insurer here and they've been alerted to some interesting things that have been going on in UBC where you know off season firefighters can go around and start doing assessments on house property risk, those sorts of fairly simple, but coordinated demonstration site examples. I honestly believe if you could do one of those well, then you'd say, "Well, you know, my vision is we're going to do one well and from everything that we've learned from that, we're then going to go and do four, and then from four, we can do 16. And then before you know it, we've got ourselves a system that's beginning to work for us."

    (10:08):

    The question we have to ask is, are we wanting to lift everybody everybody up by you know a few millimetres or would it be better to lift a couple of communities up by metres, knowing that that's a demonstration and a vision thing? From those lessons and failures, we would then be able to say, "Well, we can do this at these other communities. We've got a system that's beginning to work." So imagine a partnership between an insurer and the council and saying, "Well, you know let's think about this. Is there a way we could incentivize good behaviour with their rates or with their rates and their premiums?"

    (10:55):

    I'm certain that there are many creative things that we could do or using the council to provide the resources for the assessments and then try to spin up, you know get a training programme for the arborists to come, I can't pick up the phone and find an arborist and say, "Kick my house into a pretty good state, please." That just doesn't exist at the moment.

    Scott (11:23):

    David, it was great talking to you today. This is a huge and really important subject. I really liked your thought-provoking insights and I'm sure taking some of those onboard we’ll really be able to make a difference in bushfire prevention, mitigation, and also adaptation going forward. Thanks again.

    David (11:40):

    Oh, thank you so much. I mean, it's an amazing opportunity to talk to such a critical part of the solution to adapting to the bushfire threat. So thank you.

    Andy (11:56):

    That was the second part in our two part conversation with David Bowman, who's the professor of Pyrogeography and Fire Science, and the director of the transdisciplinary Fire Centre at the University of Tasmania. David was in conversation with Scott Hawkins, the managing director of Munich Re Australasia. And in case you missed it, part one of their conversation is already available right now on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. To find out more about the topics covered in this episode, check out Scott Hawkins recent LinkedIn blog about bushfire and to read that piece, just search for Scott Hawkins on LinkedIn.

    (12:36):

    And that brings us to the end of this episode of Reinsurance Rendezvous. But do stay tuned because we'll be back in the third quarter of 2024, looking at another major issue that is shaping insurance, banking and the broader community. To make sure you don't miss any of our future episodes, subscribe to Reinsurance Rendezvous on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. And while you're there, do feel free to leave us a rating or a review. So until next time, it just remains for me to say, thanks so much for listening and goodbye for now.

    Listen to more episodes of Reinsurance Rendezvous

    Learn more about extreme weather