© [M] Munich Re [P1] AlexSecret / Getty Images - AI-modified

Bushfire (S2E2.1)

Reinsurance Rendezvous podcast

    Track image

    0:00
    0:00
    By pressing the start button, Liberated Syndication Inc. (“Libsyn”) will process personal data about your use of the player. More information can be found in Libsyn’s privacy notice.

    Listen and subscribe on: Spotify | Apple

    About this episode

    Better bushfire mitigation and future-focused sustainable practices  

    The reinsurance and insurance industry plays a central role in progressing bushfire mitigation efforts to the benefit of communities, governments and business alike. In this episode, we take a deep dive into the ways we can better address bushfire mitigation and foster future-focused sustainable practices rather than investing the primary efforts – and funds - into recovery activities.

    Both parts 1 and 2 of episode 2 are motivating conversations, with host Scott Hawkins, MD of Munich Re Australasia joined by special guest Professor David Bowman from the Transdisciplinary Fire Centre, University of Tasmania.

    Part 1

    Andy (00:06):

    Hello and welcome to Reinsurance Rendezvous, a podcast by Munich Re. My name's Andy McLean. I'm a podcast producer based in Sydney, Australia. And joining me is Scott Hawkins, the managing director of Munich Re Australasia. Hello, Scott. How are you going?

    Scott (00:21):

    Good, thanks Andy.

    Andy (00:21):

    So, Scott, as always, this episode features you in conversation with a leading voice in the insurance industry, but this time around, we couldn't quite squeeze everything into a single episode. When the two of you got together, there was just so much great material that we've decided to actually split this into two parts. So, for listeners, you're about to hear part one of a two-part conversation between Scott and... Scott, tell us, who was your special guest?

    Scott (00:48):

    My special guest today was Professor David Bowman from the Transdisciplinary Fire Centre at the University of Tasmania. David's a widely respected leader in wildfire science and also wildfire management. He's published influential research in high-profile journals. He's also provided policy advice to the government and is a highly sought after media commentator.

    Andy (01:08):

    He absolutely is. It's such a privilege to have David on this podcast. And what a crucial topic it is too here in Australia where extreme weather events have become so common. We've really experienced firsthand the devastation that comes from bushfires, so this conversation couldn't really be more timely. David obviously is well-known for his passion, but also for his tangible solutions outside of the classroom. So, Scott, can you just give us a bit of a taste of what the two of you covered in this part one of the discussion?

    Scott (01:38):

    Absolutely. We had a wide-ranging conversation. In this part one, we really focused on how Australia needs to form an adaptation pathway based on a few things, an evidence-based approach. Given the industry that we work in, evidence is very important, and we need three key things. We need to educate people as to what the problem is. We need to demonstrate what can be done, and we also would need to incentivise people to actually do what needs to be done. We also talked about how we need a shared responsibility. We can't do all of this as individuals. No one part of the chain can do all of that as needed. So, here, we really need to work with governments, with the community, and also the insurance industry. And what is clear is we need to start thinking about the future with a sustainability mindset.

    Andy (02:25):

    Yeah, absolutely right. And that really came through loud and clear from this discussion. Can't wait to share it with our listeners, Scott. So, why don't we jump in and hear the conversation?

    Scott (02:36):

    Hi, David. Welcome to the Reinsurance Rendezvous podcast.

    David (02:40):

    Yeah. Thanks, Scott. Pleased to be here.

    Scott (02:43):

    So, David, if I reflect on what's happening in our environment, clearly the environment's changing. We've got hotter and drier conditions and that's very much evident in the Black Summer bushfires of a couple of years ago. Basically, we need, and we'll have to adapt as a community to this changing environment. What I really like about your work is you take things more from a theoretical perspective and then make them practical, so the how we can actually move things forward.

    (03:12):

    So, from your perspective, what do you think we need to do as a community and as a country to adapt to this changing world that we're going to see from a bushfire perspective?

    David (03:23):

    We need communities to be motivated, incentivised, to change their behaviour. We need legislation and administrative processes to streamline changed behaviour. And we need not repetitively saying that the climate's changing or looking into a numerical crystal ball and worrying about 2040, we need to be actually getting on with it now. And so, that then leads to the question of relevant education and relevant demonstration. And it's like a juggling act. We've got to get all of those things right. But there are lots of challenges of navigating through those barriers or attractors that are holding us into what I see as a maladapted state and switching ourselves from a vicious cycle where we can't do anything to a virtuous cycle where we have virtually a self-correcting system, and it's declared there's going to be a terrible fire bearing down on Hobart or bearing down on Canberra and everybody goes, "So? So, It doesn't matter because we're adapted."

    Scott (04:45):

    Yep. That's really interesting, David. And I guess there, and if we think about how we usually address these things as an industry or as a community, is to develop some sort of a strategy or a pathway if you would. We're really talking about educating people, demonstrating what can actually be done and incentivising that. What, from your perspective, would be a couple of concrete things in how we really need to do those three elements to really make sure we forge the right path?

    David (05:13):

    Well, I can give you two concrete examples and one literally is concrete, and that's fire bunkers. And fire bunkers are a beautiful example of the arrested development of adaptation. In the inquiries into the 2009 fires, unfortunately a lot of people died in place. And so, that led to some really serious soul-searching in the inquiry and it led to two recommendations. And one has now become nationalised, which is the idea that we should all leave early. Most people, they will leave late because that's what humans do. They like to defer, they like to wait.

    (05:55):

    So, what happened with the exception of Victoria is that it's not easy to have a fire bunker in fire-prone environments. Say, here in Tasmania, it's a famous case of a couple having been taken to court and having to plead guilty for installing a fire bunker. And the reason they had to plead guilty is because there was no simple administrative pathway for them to install a Victorian-designed bunker. So, obviously, what you need to do is you need to go back to the politicians, to the agencies and say, "Well, this is nuts." You know, it's like seat belts, you know, it means that if you're in a car accident, you're increasing the odds of surviving, or an airbag.

    (06:43):

    Then, it becomes everybody becomes an armchair lawyer and they go, "Well, we're frightened. If we encourage people to have bunkers, then we might be liable if they misuse the bunker, or something goes wrong and they get trapped in the bunker, or they get baked in the bunker. You know, So, we don't want to be liable for that. So, the safest thing for us to do is to discourage bunker use." Now, what that's actually doing is moving the bubble under the plastic because we know that people are going to leave late, so soon we are going to be confronted with a very horrible reality of a whole lot of people dying in a traffic jam because we know that's what humans are going to do. They're going to leave late, they're going to get overrun by fires. It's happened in Australia, it's happened in many other countries.

    (07:36):

    And so, it would be, in my opinion, putting our heads together and saying, "Hey, you know, there are Australian guidelines for bunkers. There has been thought about. It has been at least the pathway developed in Victoria. Why don't we see this as something which could be led nationally, something like you know the National Emergency Management Agency to actually facilitate and streamline bunkers?"

    Scott (08:03):

    So, you mentioned up front, you had two examples, bunkers being one of them. What was the other one?

    David (08:08):

    Let's imagine that we were able to do the necessary research, and some of it has been done to have bushfire irrigation systems, if you will, or sprays and sprinklers that could be activated by homeowners before they retreat to their bunker to save their house. Now, you imagine how good that is. And I'm currently investigating, as a citizen, the development of a spray system for my holiday house. Now, it turns out it's very difficult to find somebody to advise you on how to install a spray system. And you've got this perfect example of limited R&D, no national standards, no accreditation of an installer, therefore very limited uptake. You want national standards, you want accreditation, just like sprays in a building.

    Scott (09:04):

    So, how might insurers contribute to the kinds of steps you've just described?

    David (09:09):

    Wouldn't it be fantastic if the insurance industry said, "You know what? That's actually a good thing to have a bunker and a spray system because then the likelihood of your house burning down is going to be significantly lower because you've obviously invested in fire preparation and you're focusing your mind on your fire risk and you're walking the walk and you're investing money. But you've also got the security that you've got engineers behind it and you've got accreditation and you've got inspections and so on." So, the insurance industry would be therefore inclined to give you the benefit.

    (09:45):

    Now, if you had that, you could get a virtuous cycle going because then you get economies of scale, because suddenly, manufacturing bunkers and having Jim's Bushfire Sprays suddenly becomes a plausibility, not an imaginary proposition. So, what I think really we're trapped in maladaptation and these feedback cycles of limited legislation, limited approval processes, limited education accreditation, limited scale in market, and really no clear incentive.

    Scott (10:26):

    So, let's think positively, just imagine if we get this right, how would you describe the payoff?

    David (10:32):

    The payoff is absolutely amazing. It's saving lives and saving properties. And it would be changing the risk profile particularly of our interface bushland urban interface communities. And at the moment, I'm seeing a paralysis, I'm seeing people who want some leadership, but the problem is there are all these reasons... It's like a log jam and a river, just all of these logs piling on each other as a blockage. But I think, really, I'm looking for the white knights. And I may be naive, but I really think that the price signal in insurance can be an exciting, energising and a very plausible argument to pull the logjam apart.

    Scott (11:26):

    And I think that's a really great example of how an individual can make their situation better. Reflecting on what you've just said, David, I think what's also important is that we educate all levels, both the industry, the community and government, about what we're trying to achieve. So, we're not trying to achieve, using your example of a bunker, the fact that the person then will survive a bushfire. It's another form of mitigation. It doesn't guarantee anything, but what it does do is it reduces the risk. And likewise, to your point about incentivisation, if you've reduced the risk, that should be somehow also reflected in your premium.

    (12:04):

    So, if we move away from what individuals can do, which I think is very valid, what's your perspective on what we need to do more at a community level? We talk a lot about reducing fire loads. What can we do at that community level to also reduce the risk more for a larger cohort?

    David (12:21):

    Yeah, so the community question is fascinating because one of the ideas that's now pervasive in emergency management is what's called shared responsibility, and the government sharing responsibility with the community. Now, the first point of course is that there are lots of communities and that's actually okay, you know. But the power of a community is what I call the selfish herd, where if you have enough people who are working together cooperatively, they can overcome the barriers that are going to that overwhelm individuals and they can also achieve things at scale.

    (13:07):

    We could, as a community, make certain that the community infrastructure, which is going to be critical for recovery, is well-protected. So, you could imagine not just a designated safe space, but you could imagine a safe space which has got a very you know hefty water supply, sprays, pumps.

    Scott (13:28):

    This is a really interesting point, David. How do you think we can take people as well as the communities with us on this journey?

    David (13:35):

    We need social licence. What I want to do is to be able to take people literally, physically, into the environment, take them on a journey of discovery and a community journey of discovery to build the social licence. So, what does that look like? Well, I've been given the opportunity of using some bushland that the university owns behind the Sandy Bay campus, and I want to develop demonstrations of various alternative ways of reducing fire hazard. And then, do research in those demonstrations. And then, have community groups through interpretive trails, people giving talks, and building capacity, building awareness, building social licence.

    (14:26):

    I think you know this is so existential, so critical. I don't want to fall into that trap. I want to allow the community to come on the journey. But if you haven't built the social licence and you just suddenly spring on everybody the big surprise that this is going to happen to your landscape, then all of that creative energy, all of that vibe of trying to save lives and create a better and more sustainable future will simply blow up in your face, and we don't have the time for that. So, we've got to be much smarter about probing, listening, educating and adapting to what the community is up for.

    Scott (15:14):

    I really like the term collective responsibility. I mean, often we talk about what individuals can do for themselves and that they get the benefit, but what you are really talking about here is what can people do which will benefit themselves but maybe even benefit others more? How do we make that happen? How do we change that mindset as it's about helping others as well as helping ourselves? Have you seen examples of where that's worked really well?

    David (15:38):

    That's a very good question, and I think that we've got to start thinking a little bit more sustainably rather than having a, a sort of a dependency where you fly in the aid, you parachute it in. That what we've got to start thinking about is how communities can spin up these things to be sustainable and have sustainable solutions. So, some concrete examples, for instance, grey water, how do we redirect grey water to use that for growing and irrigating firebreaks, for instance?

    (16:06):

    And these are very fascinating questions and the ray of hope in this, just like I see the insurance industry as a ray of hope is hiding in plain sight, is local government. So, imagine a facility, federal government maybe, in some way to short circuit the state barriers and allow crosstalk amongst local governments and driving local adaptation. And then, flushing out the legal barriers and the administrative barriers that have got to be surmounted. We have to push through this stuff. What we probably do need more of is what I see as case studies.

    (17:01):

    And the one good example of a case study, New South Wales government had funded a bushfire research hub, which I was part of, and we were able to provide the inquiry with fact-based information as a platform to think about the fires. What do we you know focus on you know scientific evidence, facts that we can actually you know confront, and then think about how we're going to adapt, and have some enabling bureaucracy to solve these problems? And particularly if it's working with something like the insurance industry to try to break down these blockages.

    Scott (17:40):

    David, I really think you've hit the nail on the head with an evidence-based approach. This is exactly how we operate in the insurance and reinsurance industry. It feels like we have a lot in common here.

    David (17:52):

    That's certainly the case with the insurance industry. It’s so, we're both interested in evidence, we're both interested in outcomes. Sort of you know, we're on the numerical side, we're interested in geography. We understand natural hazards you know are not uniform. They're uneven and they're episodic. That's a really fantastic alliance. And those alliances can then be built to other alliances. What a cool thing that is. And then, you've got a social justice benefit.

    (18:23):

    One of the great things about the indigenous community is they look at the world and society quite differently. And so, they're able to, ask questions and or pose provocations that can actually be catalytic they understand fuel management. But the type of fuel management that they're promoting is wildly different from industrial-scale fuel management. It actually scales a lot better to interface communities because they're cool burns, small burns, or actually family-friendly burns. 

    (19:00):

    And then, that has all sorts of other benefits of helping people understand fire as part of the environment. I think focusing on alliances and unexpected alliances the alliance with landscape design, green spaces and community gardens. You know you could have a community benefit. 

    (19:23):

    One other thing that I did want to mention is that a lot of these interventions are very, very important for the wellbeing of younger people, who are being presented with insurmountable problems. There are all of these ripple effects that follow with the sort of stuff we're doing. And so, there are opportunities here where you know you might never have thought about it.

    (19:48):

    The worst thing we can do in my opinion, is to have the nanny state signing on to do it all for us. And so, people just sit around and they're just disempowered and disengaged and their basically, they're passive and passengers, not drivers. So, yeah, there's lots to think about there for sure.

    Scott (20:09):

    So, David, thank you. Much food for thought there. We'll have to leave it there for part one of this discussion. But David, in part two, I'm really keen for the two of us to really address the economic realities of managing bushfire risk, including some of the barriers as well as the incentives in front of us.

    David (20:26):

    Yeah. Thanks, Scott. I'm looking forward to continuing our conversation.

    Andy (20:34):

    That was part one of our two-part conversation with David Bowman, professor of pyrogeography and fire science and the director of the Transdisciplinary Fire Centre at the University of Tasmania. David was in conversation with Scott Hawkins, the managing director of Munich Re Australasia. And if you want to check out part two of that conversation, then keep your eyes on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. Part two will be dropping in the next few days.

    (21:03):

    In the meantime, thanks so much for listening to this episode of Reinsurance Rendezvous, a podcast by Munich Re. To find out more about the topics covered in this episode, check out Scott Hawkins' recent LinkedIn blog about bushfire. And to read that piece, just search for Scott Hawkins on LinkedIn. And to make sure you don't miss any future episodes, including of course, part two of this conversation with David Bowman, please subscribe to Reinsurance Rendezvous on the usual places, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to your podcasts. Oh, and while you're there, do please feel free to leave us a rating or a review. We'd be very grateful if you did. Until next time though, thanks so much for listening and goodbye for now.

    Listen to more episodes of Reinsurance Rendezvous

    Learn more about extreme weather