© [M] Munich Re [P1] AlexSecret / Getty Images - AI-modified

The risks and rewards of green technology (S2E1)

Reinsurance Rendezvous podcast

    Track image

    0:00
    0:00
    By pressing the start button, Liberated Syndication Inc. (“Libsyn”) will process personal data about your use of the player. More information can be found in Libsyn’s privacy notice.

    Listen and subscribe on: Spotify | Apple

    About this episode

    The reinsurance and insurance industry can play a leading role in steering nations toward a greener future. In this episode, we take a deep dive into the world’s energy transition – highlighting some cutting-edge technology, emerging risks, and potential rewards. We also discuss how Australia could be uniquely poised to contribute to (and benefit from) the transition.

    In this eye-opening episode, host Scott Hawkins, MD of Munich Re Australasia is joined by special guest Roman Beilhack, Global Head of Green Technology, Munich Re.

    Soundbite as an intro

    “Australia has a lot to gain. The world is behind achieving net zero by 2050. So it’s happening. In future, Australia will be able to export renewable energy. You’re better placed in Australia to do so than most other countries are. Don't wait and don't doubt.”

    Andy McLean  00:02

    Hello and welcome to Reinsurance Rendezvous, a podcast by Munich Re. My name is Andy McLean. I'm a podcast producer based here in Sydney and joining me is Scott Hawkins, the managing director of Munich Re Australasia. How're you doing, Scott?

    Scott Hawkins 00:17

    I’m good, Andy. It's great to be back doing another podcast. 

    Andy McLean  00:21

    Absolutely, and as always, we're featuring you in conversation with a leading voice in the insurance industry. So give us the big reveal! Who did you speak to in this episode?

    Scott Hawkins 00:29

    So in this episode, I spoke to Roman Beilhack. Roman’s responsible for green technologies at Munich Re and Roman’s based in our head office in Munich. 

    Andy McLean  00:37

    Now, that's really interesting so, given that Australia has made a firm commitment to achieve net zero emissions by 2050. Green tech is going to have a massive part to play. And if we think about what “green tech” means we're talking about sustainable forms of energy. So solar, wind, hydrogen. And Scott, give us an idea of where the insurance industry comes into that. That was presumably where you and Roman took the conversation? 

    Scott Hawkins 01:02

    Absolutely Andy. So really, we focused on what are the technologies that are needed, and some of which you just covered. We then went on to discuss: and what are some of the risks that come along with those technologies. And there, the insurance industry and the reinsurance industry have a role to play. And in fact, as we learned in the podcast, actually already have done a lot in how to assist in mitigating and managing those risks to enable a greener future.

    Andy McLean  01:26

    Awesome, that sounds fantastic. Well, let's jump in and hear the discussion.

    [Music fades]

    01:35

    Scott Hawkins

    So Roman, I think it's universally accepted that we need an energy transition away from fossil fuels, to greener ways of delivering energy. If we don't do that, we have no chance of achieving net zero by 2050. Your team are the experts in green technologies, what are the sorts of technologies that you or your team are looking at? And what do you see as the priorities to assist us in that transition?

    02:00

    Roman Beilhack

    Okay, that's a good question. So let me try and give you a simple answer. 

    So, on the one hand, what we need is simply more renewable energy produced by solar and by wind. The more renewable energy we are producing from solar and wind, the more we need storage capabilities, for the excess that is produced in certain times, and a lack of production in other times. So storage, in other words: industrial size batteries. 

    And then another important component is hydrogen-related technologies. For certain applications, electrification won't work so well. Using batteries won't work so well. So for those we need hydrogen-related technologies, and that is electrolysers, producing the hydrogen in the first place. And then fuel cells at the other end, to turn the hydrogen back into electricity where it is needed. 

    And the last one that I want to mention is carbon capture and removal. So net zero isn't going to happen if we don't take massive amounts of CO2 that's already in the atmosphere, and bring it back to where it originally came from. Meaning, you know, put it back underground, into essentially, from where the oil and the gas came from. 

    Those are the four large components that we look at.

    03:41

    Scott Hawkins

    Thanks Roman, that's really interesting. If I think about those sorts of technologies, I'm assuming what they need is sun, wind, a lot of space, a quite stable political environment. If I think of Australia, we have all of those things in abundance. However, if I reflect on Australia, and where we are in that transition, we seem to be further behind what I see in other parts of the world. What have you seen globally, that has assisted other countries in fast-forwarding that transition?

    04:13

    Roman Beilhack

    Yeah, I think what is needed is, first of all, there needs to be a social and a political debate, right? Because what we're looking at here, with regards to the energy transition, is the complete replacement of the energy-producing and energy-using capital stock. The International Energy Agency estimates that between now and 2050, investments of around about US$150 trillion are being needed to achieve the global net zero goal. To put that into perspective, that's about 100 times the GDP of Australia that's needed globally to make these investments. 

    So it's a huge transition. And that transition, obviously, you know, with like every change, it will have winners and losers. And going back to what I just said, there needs to be a social and political debate and will, to actually make this change. Now, when we look at other countries, you know, what has helped, I would say is, it's generally a mix of bringing in certain market forces on the one hand, such as a “cap and trade” system, as well as subsidies, on the other hand, to get some of these large investments into new technologies off the ground.

    05:42

    Scott Hawkins

    And if I think of Australia, one of the debates we've had here is we haven't had bipartisan support for a transition between the Labor Party and the Liberal Party. In the change of government, there seems to be more of a will now to do the transition. From an economic point of view, for Australia, it really means walking away from what some of our core industries are, because our core industries are fossil fuel. 

    If I link it back to Netflix of many years ago, it was about totally turning that business around from being a rental to a streaming service. For Australia, it's about going from digging fossil fuels out to doing green transition. How have you seen other countries tackle that? Is it about re-skilling? Is it purely about funding? What have you seen elsewhere? 

    06:24

    Roman Beilhack

    It's really a mix of different things. Right, so if we look at the technology side of this, you really need a whole ecosystem for the energy transition to become viable and to bring in these new technologies. You need technical training, you know. Somebody needs to install solar panels, for example. You need Universities where you train engineers. You need research institutes, you need startups who develop new technologies, you need venture capital funds, financial institutions. So it's really being aware that to bring in these new technologies, and new power producing systems, ecosystems, you need a broad variety of players who all need to work together.

    07:20

    Scott Hawkins

    So Roman, so far, we've talked really the big picture: the ecosystem of the energy transition. 

    What's the role of the insurance and reinsurance industry at a more granular level in how to actually help this transition come to fruition?

    07:33

    Roman Beilhack

    I think when you make these huge investments, there are obviously big risks associated with them. And on the one hand, you have the traditional property risks, both for the construction phase and the operational phase of a particular renewable energy project. 

    Those insurances already exist and have existed for many years. But there are also a number of what I would call more entrepreneurial risks. And one is the delay that you may face in the completion of a new renewable energy related project. And there is so called liquidated damages insurance for that, that takes out that contractual liability for the delay risk. Then once the project is completed, you face performance, non-performance or under performance risk if you have made an investment in say an electrolyser plant. And we provide performance guarantee insurance for essentially, all the new technologies that are associated with the energy transition, be it solar panels, wind parks, fuel cells, electrolysers. 

    Another entrepreneurial risk then is think of solar plants or wind farms. There is a risk that the sun won't shine quite so much. And the wind won't blow quite as hard as you had expected. It is possible to buy parametric solutions to reduce that risk as well. 

    And the last one that I want to mention – also in a way an entrepreneurial risk – is to insure carbon credits from defaulting. So, you know if I look at this broad bundle of risk mitigants I would say the insurance and reinsurance industry is really at the forefront of making the energy transition possible by taking out a whole number of risks that come with the investments.

    10:00

    Scott Hawkins

    What we're saying here is really the impetus needs to be provided by pre-funding; giving a benefit, giving a subsidy to really bring people across. If I think about some of what I've read, when we think about the transition, there will be an initial cost. Some figures have put it as sort of 1% of GDP as a cost, which could actually drive inflation in the short term for a long-term benefit. Is that something that you think is impeding the transition – that people will only want to transition when it is already cheaper today, rather than that it will be cheaper tomorrow?

    10:36

    Roman Beilhack

    Absolutely. I think that's absolutely the case. 

    And Scott, one other thing, if we look at this at a global level, I said this earlier: We have to make investments of let's just say around about at a global level of 100 times the Australian GDP. At the end of this investment at the end of this period, there will be no additional output. Right, that's something that people don't like to talk about politically or socially, it may be different for different countries. 

    And I think Australia is in very good position. You know, it brings many challenges with it. So as I said, globally, we make all these investments, and we get nothing for it, you could argue, of course we do. We get a less hot climate, fewer natural catastrophes, you know, fewer droughts, fewer storms, less inundation from precipitation, excess precipitation. But we get no additional output, that's at a global level, right. And that's an uncomfortable thing to think about. 

    If you look at specific countries, it may be very different. And obviously, since we're talking or focusing on Australia here, I think Australia has a lot to gain. You already mentioned a stable political climate, you have certainty of law in Australia, these are extremely important things here, financial institutions, but you also have a lot of space, and you have a lot of wind, and you have a lot of sun. And these are obviously excellent preconditions for making the energy transition not just work, but get something out of it. 

    Australia, you know, you are exporting so much coal and gas to other countries, making money for that, or getting money for that. In future, Australia will be able to also export renewable energy, whether that is exporting electricity directly by you know undersea, underwater cables; or in the form of hydrogen, for which I think Australia is also excellently placed, again, because you have so much wind, and so much sun, which is needed to produce the renewable energy from which you then make hydrogen that you can then export.

    13:06

    Scott Hawkins

    Roman, thanks for that discussion today. What would your key message be for Australian business leaders in their green energy transformation?

    13:14

    Roman Beilhack

    So my key message would be: Seize the opportunity. Don't wait and don't doubt. Right. The world is behind achieving net zero by 2050. Just think about the recent COP, the so called Conference of the Parties of the United Nations Climate Conference that took place in, in Dubai. There it was agreed that all the member countries will transition away from fossil fuels. And remember, this conference took place in Dubai. And it also got the oil exporting countries from that general area and many other countries in the world or areas in the world behind that goal of transitioning away from fossil fuels. So it's happening. Don't wait. Seize the opportunity. You’re better placed in Australia to do so than most other countries are.

    14:16

    Scott Hawkins

    And I think Roman, reflecting on our discussion, there's sort of two really important points I think to come from this. 

    One would be: We focus a lot about the cost to end up back where we are now. And you put that in terms of output. I think the one area where there's not enough discussion, which you rightly pointed out is “What's the cost that will come from not doing this?” And that then really is: “What does that do to the climate? And what does that do to the country, or any country?” 

    And I think the second one that I take away from this discussion is particularly for Australia. It's really about replacing one natural resource with another natural resource, which puts us in a better position to some other countries who maybe only have one natural resource, and they can't replace it with a green one. And I think if we focus on that, then we focus on what the real benefit is both for everyone, but also for Australia as a country.

    15:15

    Roman Beilhack

    Absolutely, I agree. Yeah. 

    Scott Hawkins

    Thank you, Roman. 

    Roman Beilhack

    You're welcome. Thank you.

    Andy McLean  15:23

    That was Roman Beilhack, who is global head of green technologies for Munich Re in Germany, in conversation with Scott Hawkins, the managing director of Munich Re Australasia. 

    Thanks so much for listening to this episode of Reinsurance Rendezvous, a podcast by Munich Re. 

    To find out more about the topics covered in this episode, you can read Scott Hawkins recent LinkedIn article about green tech. To find that piece, just search for Scott Hawkins on LinkedIn. 

    And that brings us to the end of this episode of Reinsurance Rendezvous. But do stay tuned, because we'll be back in the second quarter of 2024 looking at another major issue that is shaping insurance, banking and the broader community. To make sure you don't miss that or indeed any of our future episodes, subscribe to Reinsurance Rendezvous on Apple podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. And while you're there, feel free to leave us a rating or a review. 

    So, until next time, thanks again for listening. And goodbye for now.

    [Music fades]

    Listen to more episodes of Reinsurance Rendezvous

    Learn more about extreme weather