Resilience and Disaster Recovery (S1E3)
Reinsurance Rendezvous podcast
About this episode
The time for change is now. Decisive action is essential. How do we bring the various elements of the system together to tackle the problem of resilience and disaster recovery and what does an holistic approach really mean? What can we learn from New Zealand following their experience of devastating natural disasters? In this episode, we answer all these questions - and more - with host Scott Hawkins, MD of Munich Re Australasia and special guest Dr Jo Horrocks, Chief Resilience and Research Officer, Toka Tū Ake EQC.
Episode transcript
Andy:
Hello and welcome to Reinsurance Rendezvous, a podcast by Munich Re. My name's Andy McLean. I'm a podcast producer based in Sydney. And joining me today is Scott Hawkins, the managing director of Munich Re Australasia. Hello, Scott.
Scott:
Hey, Andy.
Andy:
So Scott, as always, this episode features you in conversation with a leading voice in the insurance industry. Who did you speak to today?
Scott:
Today I spoke to Dr. Jo Horrocks. Jo is the Chief Resilience Officer for Toka Tū Ake EQC. Together, we talked about resilience and disaster recovery.
Andy:
Okay. So her organisation's a New Zealand government entity, it invests in natural disaster research to help communities reduce risk. And the organisation also provides home insurance to help communities get their lives back on track after an event. So what did the two of you cover?
Scott:
Two things. The first was really about the recovery effort and what New Zealand has learned from natural disasters, like the earthquake sequence that happened in 2010 and '11, and what other countries might actually be able to learn from this. The second thing we talked about is what does a holistic approach to resilience and disaster risk management really mean? And how do you come up with a fact base to prove what you want to do into the future?
Andy:
Fantastic. It sounds like you've covered a lot of ground and we've got a very short space of time to share it. So let's jump in and hear the discussion.
INTERVIEW BEGINS at 01m50s ENDS at 16m40s
Scott:
Jo, we're seeing a very large increase in natural disasters, both globally and then also in our region. Often when we talk about resilience and disaster recovery, the discussion is really about what should we do in the future? If I put the lens on New Zealand, it's really about what New Zealand has done in the past and where it's learned from events as they've unfolded. How would you summarise what New Zealand has done in this space?
Jo:
12 years ago we had the massive Christchurch earthquake, or actually the Canterbury earthquake sequence, which is really seminal in our memories, in our understanding, and has driven a lot of what we've done over the subsequent decade. Such a big event, so shocking to the whole nation, actually, that it couldn't do anything but drive progress. It had to for the memory of those people, for the devastation that happened. So that has driven a lot of corrective action, including through some quite important pieces of legislation, including through our policy planning and practise to get to where we are now.
Scott:
And yes, certainly the Canterbury earthquake sequence in 2011 was alerting for all of us; both the insurance industry, the New Zealand government, and the reinsurance industry. If I think, though, about the response, the response has been rather a collective one. And certainly some of that was driven by what we learned through the Canterbury sequence, but that's something that I'm not seeing in other countries. And they seem to be struggling more with this collective response, whereas in New Zealand you derived a really holistic one. How did New Zealand get to that point of being able to have a holistic response to these types of events?
Jo:
Yeah. So again, I'll point to the Canterbury earthquake sequence because what was very apparent through that event or that series of events was that a disaster touches every part of society. And I was actually in the Civil Defence Ministry at the time, and subsequently developed a national disaster resilience strategy. And we were very conscious through that process to make sure that there were responsibilities for all departments across government. It was as much an economic issue, a social issue, as it was about buildings and land and insurance. So that's something we've certainly tried to engender and build into our policy and planning in this country. And I think it is a challenge that most parts of society have taken up, again, because we've seen the impact that it can have.
Scott:
And if I think back to particularly the Canterbury sequence, there was certainly some big decisions to be made, and some decisions which maybe not everyone was comfortable with or wasn't necessarily what they want. It's a discussion, if I think back to Australia, we have at the moment with flood, and really about buying back properties. And we haven't been so successful in Australia, whereas in New Zealand that really has been a success story and really talked about bringing resilience both where currently building stock is, but also into the future. How would you describe that for others? What did New Zealand do and why did it work there where it hasn't been as successful in other parts?
Jo:
I think there's two main factors, actually. Certainly we've seen successive governments are willing to act. They've been very responsive. So disaster response, disaster recovery, hazard risk management is seen as an apolitical issue. It's not something that gets challenged. Any new piece of legislation that goes through, for example, there's a new emergency management legislation going through at the moment, there's a certain level of agreement that it's not a thing to do politics over. But certainly post-Canterbury, a number of new pieces of legislation were quite quickly passed through the House in order to fix some really obvious problems.
For example, in the Canterbury earthquake, 580 unreinforced masonry parapets collapsed, killing something around 40 people. And that was quickly pushed through in some legislation to make sure that unreinforced masonry was all secured and strengthened. I don't know if that's because it's kind of expected by New Zealanders. I don't know if it's a small country, a small community of people that expect to support each other, including through legislation. But certainly we've always seen that response from governments.
Scott:
Reflecting on New Zealand, I think also if you think of the scale of the events, if you think of Christchurch, it impacted everyone who lived in Christchurch.
Jo:
Yes.
Scott:
Whereas in other parts of Australia or even other countries, often it's a select few who are impacted. So I think also having that broader scale helps get the entire community buy-in. I think the other thing that I learned certainly through the Christchurch earthquake and I think is certainly applicable to others is building back better. And when I mean building back better, building back in a way that properties should be built given the hazards that they're exposed to. And if I think about the change in construction in Christchurch post the earthquake, I think that's a really positive story. Was that something that you would see as easy to achieve? Or what were the challenges in trying to get that through?
Jo:
Yeah. So insurance is both supportive and hinders progress in some respect. The expectation in insurance policies often of reinstatement to the existing, or the previous standard rather. That is a bit of a barrier and something that we've had to try and overcome. And I'm not sure we're quite there yet. I mean, I would like to see replacement to a new better standard. That's something I think on the agenda for the future. Certainly through the most recent event, the Cyclone Gabrielle storms and flooding, we've certainly seen a willingness both from builders, insurers, and councils to instigate flood resilience measures both in terms of the rebuild and in flood protection works and other risk-mitigating factors. So that resilience mindset is there.
Scott:
I think flood resilience is a really good topic that you've raised. So we have the current challenge in Sydney where I live. In the western part of the city, it's very exposed to flood. In fact, there's a town, Windsor, that has flooded multiple times in the last couple of years. The local council is still doing planning permits to build in flood prone areas on the premise that we just need to make sure that there's a good escape route, which of course is not what we're wanting to do in protecting. In New Zealand, it seems to be more of an integrated approach. And I think EQC has done a really good job in influencing the planning codes going forward. What has New Zealand done here that we should learn from in other parts of the world?
Jo:
Yeah. Well, we're in the process of doing that. And I certainly have a huge amount of optimism for the future. So we are working in partnership with Ministry for the Environment on the development of a national policy statement for natural hazard risk management, which is a huge development. Some of the things we're trying to get in regulation, required policy for local governments, that's a best available science and data into regulation like hazard mapping. What's the standard that should be at? And then introducing a risk-based approach that is underpinned by a risk assessment and a risk tolerance assessment importantly. That's the kind of new bit that we really think is missing. And then link that to the required risk management. The other aspect that we're trying to get in regulation then is minimum timeframes for risk assessments.
So, something like the 1% AEP for any flood or climate hazard, and maybe down to 0.1 AEP for some of the geological hazards. But getting that risk assessment over those required timeframes. It's not a point in time, it's looking out into the future. The other key things that we really want to become normal practise is taking a precautionary approach. So where we're a little bit uncertain about the timeframes or the impact, let's be cautionary right now because we don't want to build in that extra risk for the future. And finally, the thing we're trying to encourage is pre-event land use planning. So let's plan now for if there's an event in the future, how would you rapidly react in terms of things like managed retreat? Because we know managed retreat is a lot easier post-event than it is pre-event, unfortunately. But let's have some of that thinking in place right now about what you would do if you're affected by that next flood. So yeah, just a few key things there we're really trying to get into the national policy planning space to ensure we're better faced for the future.
Scott:
So in New Zealand, you're in a unique position where you do research into natural hazards and also take a lot of the natural hazard risk for the country if I think about the earthquake exposure through homeowners. Do you see an advantage in that model? Has that helped you in being able to better influence land use planning, building codes in New Zealand?
Jo:
Yeah, absolutely. So, I mean, Toka Tū Ake EQC has always invested in research and education on natural hazards and ways to reduce impact. And I think in the past it's been a little bit more passive. I mean, always tried to get that out as widely as possible. But certainly over the last few years we're trying to influence and advocate for the change that we want to see. Because we see the impact of it, we've got such a vested interest in reducing risk and reducing impact for the future. So we are taking the lessons from science research data, previous events, and trying to put those in the hands of the people that can make a difference.
And as we see it, we tried to do that in four main areas. That's central government policy and legislation, it's local government planning and implementation, it's private sector practise, particularly some key disciplines like geotech, engineering, planning, architecture, and then it's the public in terms of public appetite and demand for resilient solutions. So we certainly see that as our resilience agenda, if you like, and a bit of a pipeline actually from research and science at one end, influencing and advocating and hopefully implementation and action.
Scott:
Jo, if I summarise that, it really seems that, to be successful in this area, we really need a holistic approach. And that's involving both those who take the risk, those who are exposed to the risk, and those who are responsible for planning and managing the risk. And that's something where I think we don't see in other countries. So I think that's a really positive thing for New Zealand. What would your advice be to other countries who are trying to improve and create this holistic approach?
Jo:
Yeah, that's 100% the approach that we try to take, a holistic approach looking at the whole system. Because we know it's never one decision, right? It's never one thing that leads to a bad outcome. It's the whole Swiss cheese, the lining up of several decisions, several contexts that lead to a bad outcome. So we try to look at case studies of where there maybe has been a bad outcome, and then look at the series of things that led to it. As I say, we know that it tends to be the national settings or the federal settings in the case of Australia, the legislation, the policies that are driving action, the local government implementation, how the hazard is understood, how the spatial plans and land use is implemented and how consenting is done.
And then private sector practise. Are they building in as routine, good engineering practise, good geotech investigations, that sort of thing? And is the demand there from the public? Is the risk literacy there to understand the problem and demand resilience solutions? So that is the only way, in my opinion, to really look at resilience in terms of the huge combination of factors that are driving the good outcome you want to see or the bad outcome you don't want to see.
Scott:
So Jo, we've talked today a lot about what we've learned from real events. And I think that it's really important that we have a factor and evidence-based to inform decisions going forward. It makes it easier for stakeholders to agree and understand. How has New Zealand gone through this evidence-based approach?
Jo:
The evidence-based is everything to me. If you're trying to persuade decision makers to invest a large amount of money in possibly an uncertain intervention or hazard or outcome, you need to have as much evidence as possible. You need to reduce the uncertainty as much as possible. So that's kind of been the MO of Toka Tū Ake EQC all along to have the evidence-based to invest in the science, the research, and data to enable people to make good decisions, particularly on land and buildings. So we try to increasingly target our evidence through science research data. We look at the outcome that we want to see and then work back from there. What are the layers of evidence that we need to be really compelling to make it a slam dunk essentially? To I talked to the team about weaponizing data to how do we make them as targeted as possible so that no decision maker can say no? Because that's often what we're faced with, sceptical people who don't want to invest huge amounts of money on what may or may not work.
Scott:
So I think that evidence-based approach is really important. I think another thing that you're talking there is really about making long-term decisions for the future. And I think, in many parts of the globe, it's a tough one for governments to then be spending money today where the benefit won't be seen for many years. How has that discussion been played out in New Zealand?
Jo:
Yeah, it's a tough one. I think climate change is forcing a bit of a conversation on intergenerational equity and how we plan for the wellbeing of future communities. So I think that is helping, but it's never an easy one to invest now. As much as we try to give good stories and evidence of investment in risk reduction now, a dollar now saves you $10 when an event happens. It's still an uncertain outcome often. So it's still not an easy case to make. But again, it comes back to really good evidence. And this is where I think things like cat modelling, loss modelling can come in. If we can really show what the loss is over a period of time, that's quite compelling. If we can show cost-benefit of interventions, that's generally quite compelling. Focusing on that financial argument is obviously the one that tends to resonate with decision makers. So yeah, that's, again, layering evidence always.
Scott:
Thanks, Jo. I think that was a really good discussion on resilience and disaster recovery. Thanks for joining me today.
Jo:
Thanks very much, Scott.
Andy:
That was Dr. Jo Horrocks, the Chief Resilience Officer at Toka Tū Ake EQC, in conversation with Scott Hawkins, the managing director of Munich Re Australasia. Thanks for listening to this episode of Reinsurance Rendezvous, a podcast by Munich Re.
To find out more about the topics covered in this episode, check out an article on the Munich Re website titled Mother Nature has the answer. The article looks at how Munich Re is supporting initiatives that help mitigate the consequences of weather-related natural catastrophes and how Munich Re is supporting initiatives to show people how they can adapt to climate change.
You can also read Scott Hawkins' recent LinkedIn blog about resilience and disaster recovery in which he explores some real world examples where insurance has played a part in building climate resilience. To read the piece, search for ‘Scott Hawkins’ on LinkedIn.
And that brings us to the end of this episode of Reinsurance Rendezvous. Do stay tuned, though, because we have two more episodes on the way. In October, you can hear a special bonus episode on mental wellbeing. And then in November, we'll be back with our regular quarterly episode looking at another major issue that is shaping insurance, banking, and the broader community.
So to make sure you don't miss any of those future episodes, please subscribe to Reinsurance Rendezvous on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. And while you're there, feel free to leave us a rating or a review.
Until next time, thanks so much for listening, and goodbye for now.