Affordability (S1E2)
Reinsurance Rendezvous podcast
About this episode
The time for change is now. Decisive action is essential. How do we bring the various elements of the system together to tackle the problem of affordability? What's driving the short, medium and long-term aspects and what are the potential implications on the insurance industry, government and the planning and construction industry? In this episode, we answer all these questions - and more - with host Scott Hawkins, MD of Munich Re Australasia and special guest Andrew Hall, Ceo, Insurance Council of Australia.
Episode transcript
Scott (00:01):
Hello. Welcome to the Reinsurance Rendezvous, a podcast by Munich Re. My name's Scott Hawkins, I'm the managing director of Munich Re Australia. This is a brand new podcast series. In the series we do deep dives into current and emerging issues shaping our industry. We tackle the most pressing issues in insurance and in banking and looking at how that impacts the broader community.
(00:24):
In today's episode, I speak with Andrew Hall. Andrew is the CEO of the Insurance Council of Australia. Originally a journalist, Andrew spent 10 years in federal politics and most recently was the executive general manager for corporate affairs at the Commonwealth Bank of Australia. Andrew brings this extensive experience and a strong personal passion for advocacy in complex situations, aligning the outcomes of consumers and businesses. Together, we tackled what impacts affordability, a very timely discussion in the current environment we have in Australia. In the last year, we saw nearly 300,000 claims and nearly 7 billion of losses coming from natural disasters in Australia.
(01:06):
We looked at the short term impacts of things such as supply chain stresses, inflationary environment, and how that's driving the current costs of claims. We then took a perspective more to the medium and long term to say what is going to change in our environment and how does that impact insurance affordability? And lastly, we looked ahead. How do we bring the various elements of the system together to tackle the problem of affordability. With that, here's our discussion.
(01:35):
Welcome, Andrew. Thanks for joining me on the podcast today.
Andrew (01:39):
My pleasure.
Scott (01:40):
Insurance affordability, it's a hot topic at the moment and it's one that both you and I have a real passion about and how we can improve that for the industry. Of course, we can take affordability from a number of angles, both from a short term and a long term perspective. If we focus first on the short term, from your perspective, what are the main drivers currently of insurance affordability or the lack thereof?
Andrew (02:02):
Well, Scott, I think you're thinking about it in the right way. It's short, medium, and long term in terms of how we tackle affordability. And I think the ultimate goal always with insurance, as you well know, is that we're pricing risk. And when we're pricing risk, at the end of the day, those risk drivers are what are driving the costs. There are other factors always at play including inflation, cost of capital and the like. But ultimately the things that are within our control are the risk factors. And I think across the board of all issues in Australia, the risk factors that we face the most threat from are the physical risks. So in the short term, if I think about the short term, there are ways that insurance is priced, the way it is taxed. That needs to be thought through carefully. In the medium to long term, ultimately though, it's about reducing the risk and that includes tackling climate, resilience and mitigation and a whole raft of things.
Scott (02:56):
So if we think about the short term, how can we address the short term pricing pressures for the community?
Andrew (03:02):
Well, where we're seeing these pricing pressures, often we can now trace a line and directly link them to the risk factors that people are facing. Across the board, insurance has gone up. I think the latest APRA data showed a high single digit increase in the average cost of premiums in Australia, but that could probably be sheeted home largely to inflation, to the cost of goods. As we know, post COVID supply chains were disrupted, parts are costing more. It is incredibly difficult to get a hold of trades and labour and the like. So all of that is having a ongoing effect as well into the price of insurance.
(03:41):
But moving forward where we see the really steep increases, often they're again driven by the physical risk. Homes that are located the wrong place, that flood frequently, are built to the wrong standards and we're getting more and more information and understanding about where those vulnerabilities exist. And I think that's why as a country, partnerships with government, like what we're seeing with the federal government and the Hazard Insurance Partnership, if we can identify those areas that are most at risk, what are those risk drivers, that's where we can channel our investment and try and improve those outcomes for those people.
Scott (04:16):
That's a really good point. Before we talk about the medium or the longer term, you've made reference to insurance taxes. For some of the things that we talk about, it can take a long time to be able to enact those. What would your advice be to the government when it comes to insurance taxes and how we could help that in the short term?
Andrew (04:32):
One of the things consumers don't realise is that in some states, nearly a third of your premium is going out the door in taxes and that has a dramatic effect on affordability. It reduces the total sum insured ultimately and can leave people potentially underinsured if the worst happens. In the state of New South Wales, there is an old system still in place called the Emergency Services Levy. It is probably one of the worst inefficient taxes left in Australia when it comes to insurance or financial services. It taxes insurance policy holders effectively for emergency services, where in every other state those states have found other ways to raise that revenue to fund emergency services. In New South Wales, a proportion of it is sheeted home directly to those people who do the right thing and take out an insurance policy.
(05:25):
So reform is desperately needed in New South Wales, but across the board you are taxed at both a state level and then a federal level with the GST. And that money of course goes back to the states as well. There is a significant case for reform of taxation for insurance, not the least being that it's going to be a critical weapon in Australia's future fight against climate change and the impact of climate.
Scott (05:49):
So if I hear you correctly that, Andrew, really what we're saying or what you're saying is that we should be charging those who use the services rather than only charging those who purchase the insurance.
Andrew (05:58):
It seems bizarre to punish people who are doing the right thing by taking out an insurance policy. And those who don't take out an insurance policy, the fire brigade still comes and helps. And even the design and the construct of the policy in New South Wales means that if you are a large, for example, multinational supermarket chain and you choose to self-insure or have offshore arrangements for your assets, it's likely you won't pay any ESL either. So it's an unfair tax. Queensland managed to abolish their emergency services levy more than 30 years ago. Victoria has reformed its system. New South Wales does need to reform its state-based land tax system and in doing so, it needs to consider the role of the ESL and how that's hurting families trying to pay for their insurance policies.
Scott (06:49):
That's a really interesting perspective, Andrew. Thank you. If I think about the more the medium and the long term and here you made a very valid point about the right risk signals in calculating the risk and certainly as a reinsurer that's what we do day-to-day. If I look further forward and I think about the changing climate, for some of those risks, the exposures from physical risk will only get bigger in the future. What do you think we should be looking at now in terms of making sure that we don't make that risk bigger into the future?
Andrew (07:19):
Well, first of all, there's fixing up past mistakes and then there's making sure they're not repeated. And in that regard, I think there's a couple of different streams of work underway. I think government's attention in this space has shifted their focusing more of their policy time and importantly their treasury dollars on investing in this space, but more obviously needs to be done.
We welcomed the federal government when they were elected last year, implemented an election promise that will invest $200 million a year at the federal level, hopefully matched by all the states and territories on resilience and investment. So that hopefully will build flood levies. It hopefully will provide grants for individual homes to be strengthened against cyclone and the like. It goes back and it fixes up a number of the mistakes that we've made in the past.
(08:06):
Moving forward and particularly at the moment with the population debate that's happening in this country, we're going to have to find homes for an extra minimum of 200,000 people each and every year moving forward. Creates a real challenge for our state governments as to where do these people go. What we can't allow state governments and what we can't allow developers to do is put those newly arrived migrants into houses on cheap land, which is often flood land. It just will mean that the problem keeps repeating and those people who can least afford it end up living in harm's way and often without the ability to pay for the insurance.
(08:42):
So land use planning is critically important and National Cabinet has talked about that. They passed a motion around tackling it in December last year. We stand ready to work and I'm hopeful actually in the next couple of months, the Insurance Council will come together with Property Council, with the builders, with the Planning Institute, with local government, with a whole raft of other organisations to sit down and have a discussion around what are the parameters we need to put in place as a nation around land use planning moving forward.
Scott (09:15):
And from my perspective, I think it's really important that we focus in two areas. One, very much the assets stop that we have and where people live and making that more resilient at and mitigate some of the potential exposures, but also that we don't perpetuate the problem going forward. And as you say, better land use planning and building the right houses in the right places and also built to a standard that will be needed into the future when some of those areas get even more exposed.
Andrew (09:40):
And that's correct. Having homes that are durable is the key here. We can't be building homes, apartment blocks, even commercial into standards that are not going to withstand what will be thrown at them over the next 50 to 100 years. And that's why things like the National Construction Code, which is currently in the process of being reviewed, need to consider putting resilience as a key objective at its core. And coming out of that, each and every state's building codes need to constantly be reviewed to make sure that their standards are meeting the sort of perils that their state faces.
In Queensland, it's around cyclones. West Australia and Northern Territory cyclones up to a cat five level. In the southern states it's the bushfire rating, it's extreme storms and hail and the like. So there are a raft of perils that we need to better protect our assets against.
(10:37):
And I think as a country we've invested for years and years and years in getting people to own a home. It's considered their greatest financial asset, it's part of their retirement. There is no point in putting all of your wealth into a building if it's not going to be able to withstand what's thrown at it and you can't afford the insurance
Scott (10:57):
Thinking about all of the things that need to happen, it seems that not one part of the system can solve all of the problems themselves. It will require a consolidated effort amongst various parties. How do you think we bring the various parties and sometimes even maybe competing interests to the table to come up with one solution to make it better into the future?
Andrew (11:19):
I think the collaboration is building because Australians everywhere have now been through consecutive years of extreme weather events, whether it was the bush fires that really went on for about eight or nine months, and then the flood events from La Nina from last year, which started in February and really continued all the way through into December and impacted communities right across Australia, the massive cyclones that have continued to lash the West Australian northern coast. I think the community is seeing that we do have a challenge on our hands and the job insurance does, apart from protecting assets and giving people a peace of mind, is we are price signalling the risk. So in terms of a financial services system, really insurers are doing their job in pricing what the true risk is for protecting assets. If we try to mask that risk through clever programmes or subsidies and the like, while that that is important potentially for helping low income people, the risk of masking that pricing is that we continue to make the same mistakes.
(12:24):
And what we don't want to have in the future is a country where we have large vulnerable populations living in highly exposed areas. For example, the coastline full of retirees living in poorly built homes. And we're seeing a lot of those sort of developments still happen to this very day up and down the east coast of Australia. And that's simply got to cease. And I think developers are understanding now that eventually someone pays the price, whether it's the person who buys the new home or someone who owns it 5, 10, 15 years down the track when the worst has happened. So it's important if we can put the cost up front to get a better home, it will have a much better payback on the whole system in years to come.
Scott (13:05):
And I think that's a really good point when we think about the future and it's as you say, often the biggest investment that a family has, that we also help them protect that investment, that the value of that investment could change if it ends up in a part of the country where it becomes less affordable to continue to buy insurance or simply that given climate change that the property is no longer there.
Andrew (13:27):
We're seeing what we probably could call intergenerational poverty being entrenched by extreme weather, and that's because people are living in cheap homes, in dangerous locations that flood regularly or are damaged regularly, they have trouble selling them, they can't access insurance and every time a disaster hits and they lose everything, they simply go backwards.
(13:50):
So I think what we want in this country is safer homes built in the right locations. Insurers want more people in the pool, they want more customers, not less. And I know from an international perspective, reinsurers are looking at Australia and saying, "You have got the bandwidth and the wherewithal to build better homes in better locations. You should be doing that and learning from the mistakes that you've seen already in other developed countries around the world."
Scott (14):
So the industry that we all work in has a lot of data. We're a data-driven industry. We must have the data that can also help us inform these decisions going forward. And often it's about unlocking that data. Do you think there's a way that we could come together to utilise the data in a method that's not anti-competitive to come up with the right things for the community?
Andrew (14:34):
In the discussions that we're having with the federal government at the moment around the Hazard Insurance Partnership, one of the key things we're trying to deliver is agreement around sharing peril data with government to help them make decisions around where they invest money. I think that peril data is probably the logical starting point. The way premiums are priced, they often take in a range of factors including the value of the home and even local competition and the like, whereas what's more important is the data that insurers hold to understand the perils that they're trying to price. If we can find a way to be able to share that, that doesn't compromise the IP of every individual insurer, that gives government, I guess a second or third opinion around where they should be investing money because government itself holds a lot of data as well. It can validate decisions that they're going to make about building flood levies or home improvements or buybacks or whatever it is. I think that would be a great step forward.
(15:36):
And ultimately in Australia what we would love to see is some sort of open data source for home buyers so that when people are purchasing a property, they can very easily access information around what are the flood risks, what are the cyclone or the bush fire risks for that property and make decisions around that purchase, because ultimately you can guarantee if you've got a high risk of something, you're probably going to have trouble getting insurance that you can afford.
Scott (16:03):
Thanks Andrew. So summing up the discussion, I'd say really what we're talking about is there's some short-term pressures on pricing insurance and that's driven by factors that are affecting all of us in other parts of the economy as well, if I think about inflation and supply chains. But really the bigger risk to affordability going forward is the longer-term risk. And to use your words, it's building the right types of places in the right areas and making sure we keep that risk signal to ensure that we know what we're doing, what we know what we're in for, and we can adapt to make sure that the system remains a viable one for all involved.
Andrew (16:39):
Yes, and there's effectively no silver bullet aside from doing the hard work. It's one of those bits of news that a lot of people sometimes don't want to hear. They think that maybe there is a different way of doing it. We could come up with a government reinsurance scheme or we could pool all those risks just into one community-owned fund or the like. In nearly every one of these circumstances, ultimately if you haven't reduced the risk, the cost is still there. Someone's going to have to pay.
(17:09):
And really as a country, can we afford to be subsidising everybody's risks or can we be putting that money to better use, which is building homes that are more durable in the right location. This also ultimately means that people live a safer life. I couldn't live in a home if I knew that I was at risk of a 10 metre wall of water coming through every five years potentially. That's simply unsafe. So I think a lot of these areas now we're having much more honest discussions. We're getting government buy into what we need to do and insurers are stepping up and providing the data and the insights that are needed, I think to make the right decisions.
Scott (17:46):
I think that's a really good point Andrew, and one maybe to leave the discussion on. In the end, we can't influence the severity and the likelihood of losses happening. We can try and reduce those losses through resilience and mitigation and at the end of the day, the cost will stay the same regardless of the funding mechanism of paying. Either you pay at the individual house level or you pay at a community level. So it really becomes a discussion around risk rating versus community rating.
Andrew (18:14):
And in a world with a changing climate, as you would see from your perspective, Scott, Australia is not alone in this battle. We are competing with a global market of capital and for reinsurance and the like. So we need to put our best foot forward and as a country, I think we need to lean in and try and solve this problem to make sure that we remain an attractive place for insurers to operate and for people to get the protection they need to do the things they want to do in life.
Scott (18:41):
So I think to sum up our discussion, there's a lot that needs to be done. We know what to do, we just need to coordinate so we can actually move forward and do the right things for the right reasons.
Andrew (18:52):
Talking about it is great, outcomes are more important, and I think once we can get government's commitments into action, I'll be the first one there to watch the cement being poured at a flood levy or a house getting strengthened. I think that's what we need to do.
Scott (19:06):
Perfect. Thanks Andrew. Thanks for joining me today.
Andrew (19:08):
My pleasure. Thank you.
Scott (19:10):
Thank you for listening to the Reinsurance Rendezvous, a podcast by Munich Re. To find out more head to the Munich Re website and look up a really interesting article, Flood Risks on the Rise, something that we've certainly seen in Australia in the past years. The article covers the data around floods and losses globally between 2018 and 2022. An interesting fact is that only 15% of these losses were insured, something we'd really like to change.
(21:33):
And for more, head over to LinkedIn, where I recently published the second part of a blog on insurance affordability. Here you can read about what's driving the short, the medium, and the long-term aspects causing an increase in the price of insurance, what we need to do to stem this problem and how we need to come together to ensure a sustainable and affordable industry going forward. Search for me on LinkedIn, Scott Hawkins at Munich Re.
(22:00):
Speaking of which, while you're there, tell me what you think of this podcast. We'd love to hear from you, the listeners, with suggestions on topics and guests that you'd love to hear from in the future. And stay tuned. The next quarterly episode drops in August. Here I'll be joined by an industry insider to have an informative discussion on resilience and disaster recovery, a topic that we need to get right when the time comes. To make sure you don't miss any future episodes. Subscribe to Reinsurers Rendezvous on Apple Podcast, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. And while you're there, feel free to leave us a rating and a review. Until next time, thank you for listening and goodbye for now.