Munich Re logo
Not if, but how

Explore Munich Re Group

Get to know our Group companies, branches and subsidiaries worldwide.

Full steam ahead to disaster
Full steam ahead to disaster
© Topical Press Agency / Getty Images
    alt txt



    15 April 1912: Following a collision with an iceberg, the "unsinkable" Titanic went down, with the loss of 1,500 lives. Even today, the sinking of the Titanic is considered one of the greatest maritime disasters of all time.
    14 April 1912 shortly before midnight: the lookout on duty made out a giant iceberg lying directly in the ship's path. An evasion manoeuvre was immediately ordered, but it was too late. The luxury steamer collided at full steam with the ice mass weighing roughly 300,000 tonnes. Once the damage was ascertained, one thing was quickly apparent. The Titanic would sink. Emergency calls were sent shortly after midnight and the evacuation of the ship was ordered. But it was some time before the passengers realised the danger they were in. Some people even refused to enter the lifeboats, perhaps lulled into the false belief that the ship could not possibly sink. Around two hours later, the bow had almost completely submerged. The stern was forced sharply upwards out of the water. The ship's hull broke in two. The Titanic sank. In the opinion of Edwin Mast, a technical-nautical expert at Munich Re and a seaman with a ship master's certificate, things could have turned out differently: "The scale of the disaster would probably have been diminished if the watch officer had not tried to avoid the iceberg and the ship had instead struck it head on."
    A design flaw with fatal consequences
    The ship's hull was divided lengthwise into 16 compartments, each separated by vertical, watertight steel walls. Even if four of these filled with water (which was considered highly unlikely), the ship would still not sink. But the collision tore open six of the compartments below the waterline. A single design detail would have fatal consequences: the bulkheads had not been carried up to the top deck. In some cases, the water poured into neighbouring compartments that were still undamaged. The fully submerged bow pushed the ship downwards. Eventually, the bending moments became so great that the ship's hull broke in two and the Titanic sank.

    After the shock: international conference developed safety standards

    The tragic event was a wake-up call for the leading shipping nations around the world that would lead to the establishment of stricter, uniform international safety standards. The first SOLAS (International Convention for the Safety of Life at Sea) treaty came into force in 1914, and this was revised and updated several times in the years that followed. From 1958, the International Maritime Organisation (IMO), which was established under the aegis of the UN, assumed responsibility for this convention, and since then it has worked to develop safety standards further. Under SOLAS, ships today must have room in a lifeboat for all passengers and crew, and only closed lifeboats are permitted. In addition, there must be life rafts for one quarter of the passengers on board. Special suits protect crew members from freezing during the evacuation procedure. Many passengers on the Titanic were injured because they jumped into the lifeboats from a height. Today, this risk has been greatly reduced by the use of evacuation chutes.

    Weekly fire and evacuation drills

    Unclear instructions and lack of training on the Titanic resulted in some lifeboats being launched with just a few people in them. Nowadays, passenger ship crews must undergo emergency training and take part in a weekly fire and evacuation drill. Since 1978, these regulations have been set out in the International Convention on Standards of Training, Certification and Watchkeeping for Seafarers (STCW). Needless to say, technical developments have also helped greatly to make shipping much safer today: the Titanic still broadcast on short wave using Morse code, which had extremely limited transmission quality and range. Today there are digital satellite connections virtually worldwide that can be used for communication purposes and to locate ships.

    As ships grow in size, so too does the loss potential

    Even with the latest technology, every ship is still sinkable today. The Costa Concordia accident reminded us of this fact once again, and illustrated that the human factor still plays a crucial role. Around 80% of all losses in hull insurance are the result of human error or misconduct. Edwin Mast is paying very close attention to the current risk situation: "There is an ever-growing number of larger and larger ships sailing the seas today. And the potential for major losses from an accident is also on the rise. Particularly for smaller marine hull insurers, a loss event on such a scale can have devastating consequences. We are therefore putting greater emphasis on providing support to our customers in the areas of loss prevention and professional risk management."

    Tragic shipping accidents

    1912 Sinking of the Titanic (1,500 fatalities)
    1987 Sinking of the ferry Doña Paz in the Philippines (4,386 fatalities)
    2002 Sinking of the Senegalese ferry Le Joola off the coast of Gambia (1,863 fatalities)
    2012 Running aground of the Costa Concordia off the coast of Tuscany in Italy (30 fatalities, 2 missing; as of March 2012)