Insurance Protection Gap: Invaluable lessons for Australia from overseas (S3E4)
Reinsurance Rendezvous podcast
About this episode
The insurance protection gap is a complex challenge experienced around the world. Lessons from overseas are invaluable as Australia charts its way forward. Join special guest Alix Pearce, ICA , and host Scott Hawkins as they take a closer look at both a global and local perspective, drawing insights from Alix' current research, which is both timely and essential.
Alix Pearce is the General Manager Climate, Social Policy and International Engagement at the Insurance Council of Australia (ICA) and a Churchill Fellow. Scott Hawkins is the Managing Director of Munich Re Australasia.
Episode transcript
Andy McLean 00:03
Hello and welcome to Reinsurance Rendezvous, a podcast by Munich Re.
I'm Andy McLean, a podcast producer based in Sydney, and joining me, as always, is Scott Hawkins, the Managing Director of Munich Re Australasia.
Hello, Scott.
Scott Hawkins
Hi Andy. Great to be back again.
Andy McLean
So Scott, as always, in this episode, we're featuring you in conversation with a leading voice in the insurance industry. Who's your guest today?
Scott Hawkins 00:29
Today, I had the pleasure of talking with Alix Pearce.
Alix is the General Manager Climate, Social Policy and International Engagement at the Insurance Council of Australia, otherwise known as the ICA.
Alix is also a Churchill Fellow and, as part of the Winston Churchill Trust, has recently completed in-depth research into the global insurance protection gap.
Andy McLean 00:51
Yes, and the ICA is doing some vital work to help make insurance accessible to all Australians. They're partnering with governments and communities and regulators to build a more resilient Australia, address the protection gap and ensure the strength and sustainability of the insurance sector.
And Alix's research makes a crucial contribution in moving the ICA towards those goals. So Scott, what did the two of you cover in your conversation?
Scott Hawkins 01:19
Well, currently, we find ourselves in an era of unprecedented risk. So in our conversation, Alix and I took a step back to consider Australia in a global context – and in particular, we discussed what she learned from other nations and their successes and failures.
Perhaps what's most important about that is we talked about how to take this global knowledge and use it to continue transforming Australia's resilience, because ultimately, our shared goal is to better protect communities and vulnerable people when they need it most.
Andy McLean 01:50
Well, it sounds like there's going to be a nice mix of ‘big picture stuff’ and practical solutions in this conversation. Let's take a listen…
Scott Hawkins 02:02
Hi. Alix, welcome to the show.
Alix Pearce
Thanks for having me.
Scott Hawkins
So first of all, congratulations on the Churchill fellowship for the listeners. Could you explain a little bit what the Churchill fellowship is all about? Yeah.
Alix Pearce 02:12
So in 1962, Winston Churchill spoke to the Duke of Edinburgh, and he said that – in the event of his death – he wanted a Trust established in his honour. He wanted to be like the Rhodes Scholarship, but anyone from any walk of life can apply, and you can go around the world to look at big challenges, to find solutions that you can bring back home to your home country.
So anyone from Australia, Canada, the UK, New Zealand, can apply, and they fund you to take that big adventure.
Scott Hawkins 02:43
Perfect. And that big adventure, for you, was to go to a number of countries and look at the protection gap and what we can do about it. Tell me a little bit about where you went and what you tried to do.
Alix Pearce 02:53
Yeah that's right. So I had a really fortunate opportunity to go to six countries, 11 cities around the world to look at this global challenge – which is that effectively:
- We're seeing extreme weather events worsen
- We're seeing populations expand across the globe
- We're seeing this inflationary pressure and supply chain stretch.
And what that's [all] doing is it's widening the gap between those who can afford insurance in high-risk areas and those who can't. And whilst we see this in Australia, in some of the high-risk areas, it's actually a challenge that we're seeing around the world. And that's why it was a great opportunity to go to markets in the US, UK, Europe and Asia, to look at how they're ‘leaning in’ to solve these challenges as well.
Scott Hawkins 03:35
And in doing that, what are the sorts of things that you found that others are doing?
Alix Pearce 03:39
I think it kind of falls into three areas.
- So, the first is risk pooling. What we're seeing is that the risks are now so significant that governments can't handle them by themselves, but insurers can't underwrite these risks at an affordable price. So governments and insurers are coming together around the world to form these new risk pools.
- The second kind of area is resilience. So what can we do about the risk that's already baked into our system?
- And the third area is data. How do we harness data to understand the problem and also unlock new solutions?
So I looked at those three issues in different countries and found a whole range of different responses.
Scott Hawkins 04:18
And when we look at those topics, I guess there's a big range between different countries in all of those three areas. So if we try and put that together, what are the best things that you saw? And what are some of the things that you'd say we should avoid going down that path in Australia?
Alix Pearce 04:34
I think when we think about risk pooling, it's very clear to me that in Australia, we're going to need some kind of public private partnership to tackle risk. And the pools overseas that do that really well, focus on driving down the underlying risk.
So where we see that go wrong, for example, is in markets like California, where they said, ‘Okay, let's cap insurance premiums. You can't raise the premiums.’ And unfortunately, they didn't tackle the underlying risk, which was bushfire. So the bushfire risk grew. Premiums were capped at a certain level, and then we saw market failure. So we know that we need to design some kind of solution here that doesn't mask the risk, but actually tackles the underlying risk.
Scott Hawkins 05:17
And I guess when you talk about market failure, what we really see in California is insurers leaving the market?
Alix Pearce 05:23
Yeah, exactly right. So insurers were also unable to use peril modelling in their pricing up until very recently as well. So effectively, it created a ‘perfect storm’ where insurers simply couldn't write insurance in that market, which is why they had to leave. And we don't want to see that. What we want to see is that everyone has that critical safety net when disasters strike, so that communities, businesses and economies can recover as disasters get worse.
Scott Hawkins 05:51
So that's a good example of what not to do, but what's an example of something we should do?
Alix Pearce 05:55
So I'd love to say there's one scheme that's the absolute ‘silver bullet’ that we could lift and shift to Australia, there isn't. But there's three kind of golden rules I saw in some markets that work really well.
- The first, I would say, is that in the UK, for example, and in markets like the Netherlands, they've really scaled up their resilience investment, and that is absolutely critical. We know, for example, in the Netherlands, they invest over a billion euros a year in flood defence infrastructure. In the UK, we've also seen a doubling from the UK Government in flood resilience investments. So getting that number right and making sure that investment is really targeted is critical.
- The second thing that's really key is that we stop doing ‘dumb things’. We stop building in high-risk areas that we know are going to be hit time and time again by disaster. So in countries like in Norway and in the Netherlands – and also in France – if you have a disaster, you can't then immediately rebuild net location. It has to be approved, and in many cases, you have to build back to stronger building codes and standards. So that's really effective.
- And the third thing that we know is really critical is that markets have a really clear, publicly available hazard baseline of current and future risk that informs all the policies that we're talking about. And they have one in New Zealand, they have one in the US, they have have one in the Netherlands.
So we know it's possible. And those three kind of golden rules are really important for success.
Scott Hawkins 07:24
Absolutely, and one of the things that I think about is, often people think of the protection gap, and then they say, well, that's really a third world country problem. There's no insurance in that country. And then you look at a country like Australia and say, well, there's high insurance penetration. We don't have this big gap. But that's not really true. How have you looked at that in your travels?
Alix Pearce 07:44
It’s a really good point, Scott. I mean, this is a global issue that's affecting developed and developing markets. So in Australia, we are a pretty ‘well insured’ nation. Our protection gap is about 33%.
But what we're seeing, though, is those areas of really high risk, for example, flood risk, we know that that challenge is very acute, so we're seeing premiums that are very high and out of reach for many Australians.
So it's definitely a problem that's shared. I'd also say, though, there are other markets that have even bigger protection gaps that are considered very developed. Like the US, for example, which might surprise many listeners to know, but there is a huge challenge there with insurance penetration.
So it's a universal challenge, and one that in Australia we know can be very targeted, and needs to have those policy solutions in those key locations. It's not an Australian wide challenge.
Scott Hawkins 08:35
So Alix, in the schemes that you looked at, it feels like the vast majority of the schemes focus on a single peril, whether it be earthquake or flood or cyclone. If we think about the Australian context, we have cyclones, earthquakes, floods, fires, hail – we have pretty much everything in your research. Did you find a solution that tackled multiple perils in one place?
Alix Pearce 08:58
Yeah, it's such a good point. I mean many of the people I sat down with overseas, when I showed them our disaster map, their eyebrows went up very fast. So Australia, very much is on the front line of hazard risk. But having said that, we're also one of the economies with the best adaptive capacity, and Australia actually has a lot to be proud of when it comes to our understanding of risk and how to manage it.
So by that, I mean we've done world leading schemes that actually aren't reflected in any other markets globally. So for example, we have the hazard insurance partnership, which is the only partnership of its kind anywhere in the world, where the federal government has come together with our major reinsurers, and now leading insurers, to say, ‘How do we work together to build a shared picture of risk –a shared picture of the solutions and how to target them?’. So I think that's a really impressive way that Australia has transformed our challenges into an opportunity.
Scott Hawkins 09:52
And I think to your earlier point about data, that's a good place to have one source of ‘data truth’ for everyone to use in making their decisions. Be it the industry, the government or financiers.
Alix Pearce 10:03
Absolutely, I think it's a really critical piece of the puzzle. And as I said, other countries have done it. So it's not impossible. We actually have a lot of that data already in Australia, but it's just about bringing it together, building that baseline, and importantly, making it publicly accessible as well. I think that's something that you see that's really effective in other markets, where they've made peril data publicly available in many European countries, in the UK and in the US.
So if you're going to buy or rent a house, for example, you can easily understand what the fire, cyclone or flood risk is of that property before you then buy it. And that risk literacy is critical, not just for policy makers, but also for the average Australian.
Scott Hawkins 10:45
Would it be fair to say that your reflection from the trip is that Australia's not really behind the rest of the world. In some places we're probably in front, and in some places we're further away. Where would you put us on the scale of between ‘best and worst’ that you've seen? And what are the things you think we need to do to improve even further?
Alix Pearce 11:04
That's a big question!
I think that we are one of the world leaders when it comes to resilience. However, I think our resilience investment gap remains really significant. So Australia has a critical opportunity now to say we're about to enter one of what I believe is our riskiest decades yet. Let's invest and ensure public investment the federal and state level is really focused on resilience.
When it comes to risk pooling, we do have the cycle owner insurance pool in Australia's north but unlike other markets, we haven't sat down with federal government and implemented a sort of a risk pool that's broader than just that. And I think that we actually have this golden opportunity where we have over 100 years of policy experience from around the world in building these kind of important risk pools that we can draw on to build a kind of best-in-class partnership for Australia.
And then finally, when it comes to data, I think that we have some really interesting innovations happening. So for example, we have a major reinsurer that has partnered with Google, and they've been able to build this incredible fire tool that predicts fire many years into the future.
We also know that Munich Re have done some incredibly innovative partnerships on data, including the ability to support and track storms and disasters by better using satellite capabilities. So there is innovation there, but there's opportunity to see that scaled considerably so that Australia can be a Silicon Valley of those kind of data solutions.
Scott Hawkins 12:36
I mean, one of the things, that I'm quite passionate about is actually increasing the penetration of insurance. And I think often the discussion is more around making something cheaper for those who already have it, rather than getting insurance for those who don't.
Have you seen any scheme in your travels that you’d say really did achieve that increase the penetration so more people had insurance?
Alix Pearce 13:00
Yes, so I think the UK is a good example of where insurance penetration increased, although there's now an open conversation around the longevity of the UK's Flood Re scheme, particularly because flood resilience investment hasn't been able to keep pace with the size of the risk – but also because Flood Re benefited from a pretty benign decade, and now that they're facing into worsening extreme weather, that story might may change. But that scheme has some clear examples and some features that were effective in improving the availability of flood insurance in the UK market.
We've also seen improvements, for example, that the Swiss schemes that operate have been very effective as well.
But I think there’s one stat that speaks to your earlier point that really stuck with me: I had the opportunity to go to the University of Cambridge and sit down with some very smart people to talk about these challenges, and they did analysis that found by every percentage point that you increase a nation's insurance penetration rate by, that reduces disaster recovery for that country by 12 months. It's shocking, astounding, that statistic. So you really have a clear picture that if a nation is better insured, their recovery time can improve by 12 months. So that's pretty significant.
Scott Hawkins 14:16
And on that very valid point, one of the discussions you and I had when we were in Munich was very much about also the economic benefit of that faster recovery, that people can actually be better off, or countries can be better off by having insurance.
Alix, I have to congratulate you. That's such a great piece of work and such a great asset that we now have in Australia. With your report, how do we best leverage that? What do we need to do now to get the message out there?
Alix Pearce 14:40
I think part of the reason I was selected to receive this Churchill Fellowship is because of my day job. And the Insurance Council is really well-placed working with all levels of government already to look at how we solve this challenge.
So I think I have a direct opportunity to take the lessons from that report and feed those into the conversations we're having with government currently. We now have a playbook of best practice from six countries around the world, 120 conversations across 11 cities. So how do we then use that to inform the conversations that we're already having with government?
Scott Hawkins 15:14
So it sounds like you had a wonderful trip and learned lots of things. So if I was to summarise, it sounds like Australia's in a good place. We're working on the right things when it comes to data, when it comes to resilience, when it comes to public private partnerships. What do we need to do – now to have the burning platform – to make sure things happen quickly?
Alix Pearce 15:34
The burning platform is already here, I think. The disasters that Australia has experienced in the past five years, the inflationary pressure and the cost of premiums in high-risk areas – that is the burning platform. And we're really fortunate to have a government that understands that they need to work collaboratively with the insurance industry and the broader financial services sector to solve for this challenge.
So when it comes to ‘what next?’, I think you've got all the right people around the table. So let's lean in with government and with insurers to solve this challenge so that we don't have it [during] another season of disasters and another season of unaffordable insurance. So it's really just about leaning in and getting the job done.
Scott Hawkins 16:13
I couldn't have done a better summary! Thanks for joining me today. Alix.
16:17
Alix Pearce
Thanks so much, Scott.
Andy McLean 16:22
The that was Alix Pearce from the Insurance Council of Australia in conversation with Scott Hawkins, the Managing Director of Munich Re Australasia.
Thanks so much for listening to this episode of Reinsurance Rendezvous, a podcast by Munich Re.
To find out more about the topics covered in this episode, check out Scott Hawkins’ latest LinkedIn article, which talks about resilience solutions and mitigation efforts. To read that piece, search for ‘Scott Hawkins’ on LinkedIn.
In our next episode, Scott and I will be sharing the highlights from all of our episodes from the past year. We've had some terrific guests and tackled some absorbing topics, so we're very much looking forward to revisiting those with you. That episode will be landing in your podcast feed around late January, so keep your eyes and ears out for that.
And to make sure you don't miss that upcoming episode, or indeed, any of our future episodes, please subscribe to Reinsurance Rendezvous on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. And while you're there, feel free to leave us a rating or a review.
Until next time, thanks so much for listening, and goodbye for now you.