© [M] Munich Re [P1] AlexSecret / Getty Images - AI-modified

Disaster risk: What does proactive resilience really look like? (S3E3)

Reinsurance Rendezvous podcast

    Track image

    0:00
    0:00
    By pressing the start button, Liberated Syndication Inc. (“Libsyn”) will process personal data about your use of the player. More information can be found in Libsyn’s privacy notice.

    Listen and subscribe on: Spotify | Apple

    About this episode

    Disaster risk... the challenges are complex, but the path forward is clear, and it’s one we must walk together. Join special guest Andrew Minack, First Assistant Coordinator General at the National Emergency Management Agency (NEMA) and host Scott Hawkins as they dive into what true proactive resilience looks like in action. Andrew's insights helped sharpen the focus on how data, community engagement, and strategic investment can transform our approach.

    Soundbite Intro

    “One of the challenges for government is making sure the way you communicate actually connects and resonates and is understandable to the local community. And I think this is a very complex space in terms of managing risk and improving resilience. So in terms of the programmes that we run they are community-led, they come up from effectively the grassroots to work out what can be done to improve the resilience of the community.”

    Andy (00:00):

    Hello and welcome to Reinsurance Rendezvous, a podcast by Munich Re. I'm Andy McLean, a podcast producer based in Sydney. And joining me as always is Scott Hawkins, the managing director of Munich Re Australasia. Hello, Scott.

    Scott, Second speaker, Australian (00:14):

    Hi, Andy. Great to be back again.

    Andy (00:16):

    So Scott, as always in this episode, we're featuring you in conversation with a leading voice in the insurance industry. Who's your guest today?

    Scott, Second speaker, Australian (00:23):

    So Andy, today I had the pleasure to talk to Andrew Minack. Andrew is the first assistant coordinator general at the National Emergency Management Agency, otherwise known as NEMA. Andrew brings us a wealth of experience in strategically developing, implementing, and evaluating policy and programme initiatives in very complex environments. This is integral to NEMA's purpose to help Australians prepare and recover from natural disasters.

    Andy (00:50):

    Yeah, NEMA are doing some really important work to enable secure, strong and resilient communities, not just during emergencies, but also before and after. Their vision is to build Australia's capacity for disaster resilience through meaningful partnerships and support communities when and where they need it most. What were some of the highlights from the conversation the two of you had?

    Scott, Second speaker, Australian (01:12):

    I think the highlights from today, Andy, were really the discussion we had about the changing landscape for natural disasters and how we're really seeing events happening in places where they simply didn't happen before, and the fact that we need to prepare differently going forward. I think secondly was really NEMA's role in the natural disaster management and that intersection between NEMA and the insurance industry in helping people prepare and recover from natural disasters. And lastly, I think it's the role of the industry, government, and communities and the different conversations we need to have going forward to make sure that communities and Australians can prepare for what's ahead of them.

    Andy (01:50):

    Well, there's several pressing issues there, isn't there, for the insurance industry. Let's jump in and take a listen.

    Scott, Second speaker, Australian (02:06):

    Hi, Andrew. Welcome to the podcast.

    Andrew Minack (02:09):

    Lovely to see you again, Scott, and very happy to be here.

    Scott, Second speaker, Australian (02:13):

    Andrew, for the listeners who don't know NEMA, could you outline what NEMA's role is and what are the sorts of things that NEMA gets involved with?

    Andrew Minack (02:21):

    As I think all your audience would appreciate, Australia's facing more significant fire, flood natural disasters than ever before. The Commonwealth government has created NEMA, which is the National Emergency Management Agency. It's actually a response to one of the Royal Commission recommendations in terms of establishing an end-to-end national disaster agency. We're basically responsible for leading, coordinating, and delivering Australia's national response disasters and building resilience. So Scott, in summary, basically we join the dots across government, across the private sector, including the insurance sector, not-for-profit and the community level in terms of ensuring Australians are able to prepare, respond, and recover from natural disaster events.

    Scott, Second speaker, Australian (03:06):

    Thanks, Andrew. And if I reflect on the last few years, certainly for me in my role and the industry that I'm in, we've seen a real increase in the frequency and severity of natural disasters and I'm sure you're seeing the exact same thing that we are. What do you think we need to learn from when we look at this change in the environment that we've been experiencing?

    Andrew Minack (03:25):

    Definitely events are both increasing in terms of number, scale, and even the season, what we used to call the high-risk weather season. If you reflect on the last season we've just gone through, we started with the Grampians fire in December going all the way through to the New South Wales floods in May. So one of the key reflections is we keep talking about the high-risk weather season. We're actually a 12-month-a-year season now, and we basically have these seasons overlapping.

    (03:52):

    The other key reflection I would make in terms of these events, it's one that sometimes sneaks up on people. Yes, the past is a good indicator of the future, but the future is different. And what we're seeing in natural disasters is there's events of the order of magnitude which are actually coming out of left field. And even those who are very experienced in natural disasters are actually seeing things they haven't seen before. So even the kind of what I'd call the assumptions about fire behaviour, flood behaviour, if you think of Alfred dropping down towards the Gold Coast, all these are examples of the high levels of unpredictability. And what that is causing is significant stress and strain on communities, on households, on insurance sector no doubt, on government in terms of being able to respond to those changed circumstances. And I think for all of us, it's a call to arms in terms of being better prepared, and because we do know the disasters will occur, the challenge I think for NEMA and everyone in this sector is being able to better prepare and better respond to those natural disasters.

    Scott, Second speaker, Australian (05:00):

    I think that's 100% right, Andrew. And one of the things that I think about when talking to people in the community is often people say, "We've seen this all before." So they'll make the reference to, it always floods here. I think one of the things that we need to think about from an emergency management is whilst maybe it always flooded there, what's there now is very different to what was there in the past. Is that something that NEMA is also involved with in this preparedness?

    Andrew Minack (05:26):

    Yeah, look, definitely. So Scott, just as a practical example, if I reflect on Cyclone Jasper in Queensland, it wasn't the cyclone it was the rainfall event that just dropped massive amounts of rain on a very narrow band of land. People who have seen cyclones before thought, "I know how this is going to play out," but the rain kept coming. And I think one of the challenges and one of the roles for NEMA is understanding the risk and understanding the important message that the risk has changed and it's less predictable. And in terms of people's behaviour, that needs to change as well.

    (06:05):

    And again, I've been in emergency management for quite some time. I go back to the major fire events in Victoria, we used to have a fire assessment index which would peak at the worst possible kind of scenario for a fire event in some of the bad fires during the Millennial Drought, the fire behaviour basically spiked off the graph because the graph wasn't severe enough to actually reflect the fire behaviour. And I think, Scott, that's one of the key challenges we've got in terms of communicating to the community, the changed nature of events.

    (06:42):

    And again, I think for anyone in this space, post-event, as the event recedes in people's memory, there's a kind of complacency that sits and comes back into the community because, well, you've either moved in or that was a long time ago and the memory fades. And again, I think for all of us, and we're working with states and territories about communication to the community to make sure that they're ready for the next upcoming high-risk weather season.

    Scott, Second speaker, Australian (07:07):

    And Andrew, if I think about the steps that we need to take, I mean it's clear, one is the climate drivers, so my organisation looks at that, so does yours. It's also really around what's the data that we have available now that maybe we didn't have available in the past. And third, how do we use that information with the right people to make the change? How do you see that intersection playing out going forward? What are the steps that we need to take to be successful?

    Andrew Minack (07:35):

    Yeah, look, I think that's one of the foundational pieces of information we need to know to actually then drive decision-making. And the kind of work that NEMA is doing, we're creating a national risk profile to basically be able to better map where the risks occur in some of the key hazards. In the Department of Environment, they're doing the national climate risk assessment, which is a major piece of work to actually project over the next 10, 20, 30, and 40 years impact of climate on communities. But I think what the challenge we've got, Scott, and I suspect the insurance sector has as well is converting sometimes abstract information to real-world information for communities and households. And again, I think this goes to ensuring that the work that you do in terms of community information and education hits the right mark and ensures that households have the information they know around risk and what action they can take to actually mitigate that risk.

    (08:36):

    So just as an example, a couple of examples of that. One is we've created the National Resilience Action Library, which is basically an online library of things that households can do to better prepare for a disaster. And we're also working with the insurance sector and the ABS in terms of creating a national insurance data asset, which basically is a very sophisticated profile of where the risks occur in terms of impact of insurance and insurance affordability and availability. So Scott, they're all tools that make sure households and communities and government are better informed about where the risk is and what actions they can take to mitigate it.

    Scott, Second speaker, Australian (09:14):

    I think that's really important and I couldn't agree more. And I think that's really about finding where the right information is and then putting it in the right hands. So if I think about my industry, we have a lot of information about the types of buildings and where they are and even how they would react. We then need to leverage that information for agencies like yours, other government departments in how to take that into viewing what the future looks like in terms of where to build, how to build what we're doing. If you had an ask, what would your ask be about bringing the information together? I think you give a really good example there of having one database. What else do you think needs to be done?

    Andrew Minack (09:53):

    Well, first of all, just can I compliment the insurance sector because they've shared significant amount of their data to create this national profile and working in collaboration with Australian Bureau of Statistics. So this is generally world-leading in terms of bringing this data into a single point, which then will assist with issues of insurance affordability, availability. One of the challenges for government is having a comprehensive picture about where those issues are and what are the underlying issues beneath them that actually then would drive issues of affordability and availability. And then, Scott, from a NEMA perspective, in terms of the investment we then make in terms of improving resilience, we've got an agreed picture of where the risk is and what are the actions to take. And I think, Scott, that's the challenge is for decision makers is integrating that data into a product that decision makers can use. And it actually informs where the investment is made because again, speaking frankly, there's only so much dollars we've got to invest in resilience and we need to make sure it's public money, tax payers money, it's spent in the most effective and efficient way possible.

    Scott, Second speaker, Australian (11:08):

    Absolutely. And one of the other lenses that I like to think about when we come to that prioritisation is really spending the money in the areas will have the biggest impact that we are very clear as to why we're picking one area over another and the fact that that would give the biggest impact to communities.

    Andrew Minack (11:25):

    Yeah, definitely. And again, I think for communities, for some of them when you look at the data, there are a tipping point about the sustainability of those communities. So some of the programmes we've created in terms of what we call betterment packages or resilience packages for, if I think of something like Northern Rivers in Lismore, is actually buying back the houses, which in hindsight should never have been built there before, house raising and resilience measures. So that's a programme of about $700 million to actually improve the resilience of those communities. And again, Scott, I think that's the challenge for all of us is once you understand that risk, then what is the action that can be taken? You'll never remove the risk in its entirety, but what can you do from a government, from insurance sector, from a household sector to improve the resilience of your property?

    Scott, Second speaker, Australian (12:19):

    So Andrew, in what we do, it's very analytical work and we tend to communicate in a similar analytical type way. This sort of communication doesn't really land with communities. How do we better package up our communication so communities can understand, react and implement what we really need them to do?

    Andrew Minack (12:39):

    We've actually got a network of community planning or engagement officers around the country to actually make that connection, Scott. So again, I think one of the challenges is, especially working for national government, is making sure the way you communicate actually connects and resonates and is understandable to the local community. And I think this is a very complex space in terms of managing risk, improving resilience. And at the end of the day, everyone will have a different view of the risk they're prepared to wear and the options they've got. So again, it needs to be community-led because the community understands what some of the underlying drivers are and what's the best solution for the challenges that we've got. So in terms of the programmes that we run they are community-led, they come up from effectively the grassroots to work out what can be done to improve the resilience of the community.

    (13:34):

    But Scott, there's also some key pieces of information to actually inform that conversation. For example, in terms of flood studies for local government, making sure that they've actually done that work and the engagement underneath it to ensure that people actually understand what those risks are. So when we look at the sector, there are still some key pieces of the puzzle that are missing and that's one of the key areas of focus to ensure we've got a level of understanding the risk and the work that's been done. So when you actually work out what's the policy response, what's the investment, it's built on very firm foundation of actually understanding what that risk looks like.

    Scott, Second speaker, Australian (14:12):

    Andrew, how do we take this forward in the sense of there's a clear role for both government, for the private sector and for communities? If I think of a real world scenario or situation, I think about when an event happens. So there's clearly a role for NEMA in managing that event. There's clearly a role for the insurance industry and helping in the recovery. How do we bring those two sectors closer together to have an even better outcome for the community? If I think about NEMA informing the insurance industry about where they should be deploying claims assessors, the industry informing NEMA about how they're going in the recovery process, is there a better way we could do it going forward?

    Andrew Minack (14:50):

    Well, I think one of the initiatives that we've established is the Hazards Insurance Partnership, which is a partnership between government and the insurance sector, the Insurance Council of Australia and a number of other government bodies to have that very conversation, Scott. So that's both in a strategic policy sense, but to your point about in the middle of an event, having those connection points and that forum to actually share knowledge and intelligence. So what we found super useful from the insurance sector is effectively a daily feed of insurance claims, the profile of the locations that's really useful. And similarly, we provide feedback from on the ground. Obviously, we work very closely with the state and local government emergency management agencies in terms of any issues that they're picking up from on the ground. And just as an example with Cyclone Alfred, we had a specific Hazards Insurance Partnership meeting on that specific event to make sure that we were correctly connected and prepared for that event and what are the lessons learned and the intelligence we needed to share between the insurance sector and NEMA.

    (16:01):

    And the other comment I'd make in terms of that connection point, Scott, is out of those conversations, we then brief all the emergency management ministers from around the country. So for example, last week in Darwin we had all the emergency management ministers meeting. One of the key agenda items was insurance and insurance affordability. So again, that's one of the key roles we play in terms of connection point between the insurance sector and government. And Scott, when you talk to anyone internationally and that you talk about this Hazards Insurance Partnership, the consistent response is I wish we had one of those because it's really fantastic in terms of making that connection.

    Scott, Second speaker, Australian (16:39):

    I think that's a really good point and one of the things that I thought about before our discussion was what could we learn internationally? And as a global organisation, I have a lens into what happens internationally. And I think your point is very well-made that unfortunately in this instance, we need to be the ones leading and rather informing others rather than taking in what others have done.

    Andrew Minack (17:01):

    And in terms of the relationships we have with international emergency management agencies, Scott, there's probably twofold. One is a genuine operational one. So we share resources if there's a major event either in Australia or New Zealand or Canada, the US, we're deploying people left, right, and centre in terms of, and these are incident controllers, specialists in emergency management. We then have a continuous stream of visitors to the national situation room, which is in Canberra, which is basically the hub for managing the response to any major natural disaster. It's fair to say, Scott, look, Australia's not perfect, but internationally we have got a very good reputation in emergency management and we do have that stream of people coming to Australia to basically pick up on our expertise, our approach to emergency management, our approach to recovery, to resilience, and all the other work we do at NEMA. So again, it's a reflection of where we sit internationally.

    (18:04):

    We also send staff over to various international meetings. So for example, the LA fires, we were on a study tour there last month to learn lessons from the LA fires. I was in Japan last year at an international forum basically comparing notes on what works and what doesn't work internationally. Perhaps the couple of comments I'd make a reflection on on international action. First of all, there's no magic bullet. We've looked, there isn't one. There is a consistent theme of this is really a difficult issue. There's multiple things you can do, but it is very complex. You've got community at the heart of it. A couple of comments I would make is if I look at a country like Japan where they've had tsunami and earthquakes, because they've had such a long history of that nature of that type of event, the education and even their building standards in response to that type of disaster is world-leading.

    (19:02):

    And similarly with New Zealand, some of the work they do in terms of community education, especially on earthquakes and tsunamis is genuinely world-league. So again, there are lessons to be learned from the Australia with what some of the other countries are doing. But I will also say there's also a raft of lessons about what not to do internationally. So sometimes you go overseas and there's things you do pick up and then there's some other things that you go, no, let's not go down that path. But we are continuously in dialogue with our international partners in terms of what they're doing and how we can improve within Australia or collectively.

    Scott, Second speaker, Australian (19:38):

    And Andrew, I guess for me, one of the things that my hope is for Australian communities is that we take those learnings and we implement them before an event. Not that we see an event happen and say, "Oh, we wish we had have done that before this occurred." I think that's one of the biggest lessons that I learned going through the New Zealand earthquakes back in 2010 and '11 was the lessons that could have been done before.

    Andrew Minack (20:00):

    Yeah, and can I say, it's the continuous refrain in the emergency management sector and genuine concern about thinking right now what can you do. So in a practical sense, I mean this government has created the Disaster Ready Fund, which is effectively $200 million per year to actually invest up front in terms of improving resilience. And if you look at the numbers, in 2011, on average we spent about $50 million a year. We now got a total spend of over $4 billion on resilience. And resilience is about preparedness. So there is a lot of work we do now in terms of ensuring that communities are better placed for the next event.

    (20:42):

    But again, I just go back to at the heart of that is individual and households and how they respond leading up to an event and post event. And I think one of the reflections, Scott, at the start of this conversation around how things have changed, if you look at Alfred as it was potentially heading towards a place like Gold Coast, well Gold Coast has got no experience in dealing with cyclones. If you go further north, they're well versed in it. So again, I'll just say the goal posts are continuously shifting as the weather patterns shift. And I think that's, again, one of the challenges is making sure that those communities, which historically may not have been impacted, there is now the likelihood they will be impacted and making sure they're prepared as well for the climate as it's evolving now.

    Scott, Second speaker, Australian (21:27):

    Yeah, absolutely. And if I reflect on our discussion today, I'd say there's some real positives. It seems like we're very much, if anything, ahead of the game if we look internationally, so we're doing the right things. There's a real need to have emergency management or government industry and communities involved that this is a joint task that we all need to lean into. And I think for me, the other one to leave listeners with would be we also can't be complacent because something hasn't happened in an area before. That's certainly not an indication that it won't happen in an area going forward and we're already seeing that.

    Andrew Minack (22:00):

    Spot on, Scott. I think the other reflection I would make is just on the insurance sector, what a key part of the emergency management sector it is. There's a lot of studies now about the positive impact insurance has in terms of a household or community responding to a natural disaster. I think the insurance sector's got a key role in terms of educating community. I mean, at the end of the day, you are dealing with literally millions of customers in terms of your ability to actually inform and educate communities about risk and what they can do from a household perspective I think is really important. But picking up your point, I do think Australia, and partly it's because we've gone through so many natural disasters, we have got a high level of expertise. You're right about the partnerships we develop and we need to develop them outside an event. And I think that's where the Hazards Insurance Partnership is really important. But that partnership needs to be with all parts of our community because there's only be a whole of community effort, which will enable us to respond and ensure our communities are more resilient.

    (23:09):

    From a NEMA perspective, our mission's clear, we need to bring government industry and communities together to reduce risk, respond strongly when disasters hit. I mean that's our remit, that's what we're committed to. And again, the Hazard Insurance partnership, those type of partnerships are crucial in terms of making sure the Australian community prepared for the next event.

    Scott, Second speaker, Australian (23:28):

    Thanks, Andrew. I couldn't summarise it better than that, so thank you for joining me today. That was a really great discussion.

    Andrew Minack (23:34):

    Thanks, Scott. My pleasure.

    Andy (23:39):

    That was Andrew Minack, first assistant coordinator general at NEMA, in conversation with Scott Hawkins, the managing director of Munich Re Australasia. Thanks for listening to this episode of Reinsurance Rendezvous, a podcast by Munich Re. To find out more about the topics covered in this episode, check out Scott Hawkins' latest LinkedIn article, which builds on last quarter's piece tackling risk mitigation and disaster recovery. To read that piece, search for Scott Hawkins on LinkedIn. And to make sure you don't miss any of our future episodes, please subscribe to Reinsurance Rendezvous on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. And while you're there, feel free to leave us a rating or a review. Until next time, thanks so much for listening and goodbye for now.

    Listen to more episodes of Reinsurance Rendezvous

    Learn more about extreme weather