© [M] Munich Re [P1] AlexSecret / Getty Images - AI-modified

Climate Change (S1E1)

Reinsurance Rendezvous podcast

    Track image

    0:00
    0:00
    By pressing the start button, Liberated Syndication Inc. (“Libsyn”) will process personal data about your use of the player. More information can be found in Libsyn’s privacy notice.

    Listen and subscribe on: Spotify | Apple

    About this episode

    It’s time to act. With climate change already impacting insurers and reinsurers, how should we respond as professionals, organisations, and as an industry? How can we mitigate risk and improve the resilience of assets? What part can we play in helping governments build stronger, safer societies? In this episode, we answer all these questions – and more – with host Scott Hawkins, MD of Munich Re Australia and special guest Caoimhe Adams, who heads up Munich Re’s Climate Advisory and NatCat data team.

    Scott Hawkins

    Hello and welcome to the Reinsurance Rendezvous, a podcast by Munich Re. My name is Scott Hawkins, I'm the Managing Director of Munich Re, here in Australia. In this podcast, we want to do two things, deep dive into current and emerging issues shaping our industry, and we want to tackle the most pressing issues in insurance and banking and the impacts that these will have on the broader community. In today's episode, I talk with Caoimhe Adams. Caoimhe heads up the Climate Advisory and NatCat data team here at the Munich Re Group. As a qualified actuary, Caoimhe uses her highly developed analytical skills, coupled with a strong personal passion for climate, to drive this topic for the Munich Re Group and help clients tackle this important issue. In our conversation, we tackled where we stand with the current environment and how the climate is changing, what could happen in the future if we don't do enough, and most importantly, what can be done to adapt so our communities can live in the new environment that they'll be facing into the future. Here's our discussion. 

    Scott Hawkins

    Hello Caoimhe. Thanks for joining me today on the podcast. So lately we've been hearing a lot about changing climate, what people are experiencing. Some people are saying this is a phenomena that's coming slowly. Some are saying it's something that's already here. Is this something we need to worry about now or is it something for the future? 

    Caoimhe Adams

    Hi Scott, thanks for having me on your podcast today. So I think both from the sides of the latest science and also what we can observe, especially in Australia, we are already living in a time where climate change is impacting the frequency and severity of natural catastrophes. And if we compare where we are today to pre-industrial times, the globe has warmed up by on average 1.2 degrees Celsius. Now what does that mean? That doesn't sound like a bad figure on average, 1.2 degrees Celsius, I'm from Ireland, so 1.2 degrees Celsius would actually be a good thing, a couple more beach days in the summer. But what that means actually is that it shifts the distribution of temperatures to more hotter temperatures, then that means that we are going to see the likelihood of hot days increasing. So for example, last year we saw that London reached above 40 degrees Celsius for the first time ever, which is really abnormal for that area of the world. I know Australia does get 40 degrees every now and then, but a couple of years ago you guys also had 50. 

    Now what does that also mean, is that the world isn't evenly distributed to how it'll be impacted by climate change. There are some areas in the world which are actually going to be getting drier due to this heat and some areas that are going to be getting wetter. And you might wonder why are areas getting wetter if it's getting hotter? And this is the connection that the heat has with the water systems. So you'll be in a situation where with every one degree warming, clouds will retain 6% more moisture and that will lead to heavier, more extreme downpours. In Australia, you have the situation where you have a country that is split between those two areas. 

    We can already see the impacts, Munich Re has every year a report on the main natural catastrophes that happened in that year and Australia made it into the top five, both in economic and insured loss terms, with the floods that happened in February and March in the eastern area of Australia. And these floods reached above $4 billion US in insured losses, above six in economic losses, so in total terms. 

    And if you compare this to the biggest floods before that, which were in 2010, end of 2010 and beginning of 2011, this is actually a twofold increase in those losses. So it really means a stepped difference to what was in the past. And we're seeing this a lot with these natural catastrophes, that it's not a kind of smooth increase year-on-year, that we're seeing a little bit more each year, we really see a difference of a jump or a step difference. For example, the wildfires in America in 2017, we saw this huge leap from 2016 in wildfire losses, and going on from 2017, then they've been staying at that high level. 

    Scott Hawkins

    So that's really interesting. So climate change is real, it's here with us and we're already seeing the effects. Is there anything we can do about it or do we just need to live with what we're already seeing and the impact that that will have into the future? 

    Caoimhe Adams

    There is plenty that we can be doing about it as an individual, as an industry or as a government. There's probably two aspects that I can look at here. One is the mitigation aspect, so to try and keep us below two degrees or at best, 1.5 degrees Celsius, and also for us to be able to adapt with these consequences that we're already seeing today. So when we talk about the mitigation, so keeping us below this 1.5, we have a certain amount of greenhouse gas budget left that we need to be able to not use up to reach these ambitious targets. At the moment, the policies that are in place are in no way going to reach that 1.5 degree target. So we have a lot of work to still be done to hopefully keep it under the 1.5 degree target. What does that mean? It means transitioning to a low emission economy where we are not basing it on fossil fuels, but basing it on renewable energies. 

    It also means taking into account the latest science, understanding what needs to be done and doing it. And I think there's a great report actually by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, where they advise governments on what exactly needs to be done to keep us on track for below 1.5, most probably below two. On the other side, for the adaptation, there are two areas that you can look into in adaptation. Of course, one area, being a reinsurer, is insurance. So understanding your risks and seeing what you can do to insure them, that means that you're more resilient in the future. So if something does happen to your home, you get flooded, a storm hits it, you are more capable to rebuild after such an event. And even some places, as some insurers in Australia have heard, are already offering these build back better programs so you can not only rebuild what you had already, but build it back better so it's more resilient to a storm or a flood in the future. And I think those kind of programs are exactly what we need. 

    Then also on a higher level, on a government level, there should be more done to make Australia more resilient. So I believe at the moment this split of how the funding works after a natural catastrophe event, most of it is going into the recovery. So we're talking about 97% goes into recovering after an event and only 3% goes into making it more resilient. And we need to see those numbers shift more towards the resilience side, to make sure that if an event does happen again, we're more ready for it. 

    Scott Hawkins

    Thanks, Caoimhe. I think the resilience and the mitigation are really important topics. You touched on the fact that some areas will get wetter and some will get hotter and drier. I think I've also read around some cyclones coming further south. So if we talk about resilience, how do we think of that in terms of assets that were built 50 years ago, that were really designed for a different climate to what they're going to experience going forward? Are there things that we can do there to also help the resilience of those older properties in the areas that will become even more impacted by climate change in the future? 

    Caoimhe Adams

    Definitely. And even that question of the areas that are going to become even more impacted by climate change, that's something that we, as an insurance industry, should have a really good understanding of because we have been insuring and reinsuring natural catastrophes for hundreds of years. In Munich Re, for example, we do have a tool where you can see by location what your risks are. So to first be able to understand, okay, my house is in this certain area which has a tendency or a risk or a risk classification, a flood, storm, cyclone, then you need to first understand what are those risks you're facing and then start to be more resilient towards those risks. 

    And what can that mean as an individual? You can look into it and look at what kind of measures you can take. And one example for floods is in your basement windows, having these very tough windows that don't break when it gets flooded, for example. But also as a government, you can look into understanding those risks, those areas that are impacted more likely than others for certain risks and encouraging building codes that might be slightly different for different areas, to help those, well I guess that would be new properties of course, but then also maybe supporting with subsidies, old properties to kind of become more resilient. 

    Scott Hawkins  

    So Caoimhe, as you rightly say, the insurance industry has a lot of information about the risks in various parts of the country. To what extent are you seeing that information be used in the forward planning as to where we should and will build into the future, given that changing environment? 

    Caoimhe Adams  

    I'll give you a bit of an example that's going on in the US which is a slightly different aspect of that question, but I feel like it's even more helpful in a way. So in the US at the moment, we are using our data to support communities to understand their risk, in particular flood risk of certain areas. And what we do with that is of course we give them their frequency, their severity, so their likelihood and how costly it would be if a flood event did occur. And then we work with engineering firms in the area to see what kind of measures could be taken to reduce this flood risk. And of course, thanks to understanding the likelihood and how much it costs, we can nearly build a business case for them to see, okay, does it make sense for us to invest this much money in this type of flood defense for this reduction in the probability of flood? 

    And on top of that then, we also help them understand then the overall reduction in their risk, which can help them then get the right kind of insurance they need. And then in the end we reinsure that, so we also help the insurer take the risk off their balance sheet. So it's a little bit of a different aspect, but I haven't actually seen governments yet using our models to decide on areas to build or not. I think it's a great idea that you've come up with, so I would strongly recommend it, but personally I haven't seen that. Have you, Scott? 

    Scott Hawkins

    So it's a discussion we're trying to have with government in Australia and it's very much saying, if we know what something will look like in the future, we should use that information today to end up with the best outcome going forward. And particularly if we think about the affordability of insurance going forward, it's about building, particularly when we talk about affordable housing, in areas where those people will be able to continue to afford that insurance. I think one aspect that I find really interesting is so far we've talked very much about it's quite ambitious to reduce the carbon emissions to get to the Paris Agreement or even to the 2% target. If we put our pessimist hat on, what happens if we don't do enough, what are we then going to experience? 

    Caoimhe Adams

    I guess I'm already putting my pessimist hat on if I'm always saying it's very ambitious. So I think we'll see more of what we're already experiencing today. In Australia, you have the situation where you have a country that is split  

    So you have the north and the central area, which will be seeing this kind of wetter situation and the southern and the eastern area, where you'll be seeing drier. And now what does that lead to? The southern and eastern area then you'll be seeing more droughts, more bushfires, and the northern area you'll be seeing wetter weather. Now of course the northern area is also hit by cyclones and these cyclones are also seen to be increased in severity, also this kind of rain as well.

    And what will that mean? It will mean that certain areas will first of all find it very, very challenging after such an event to always rebuild or find it very, very challenging to find insurance at affordable prices to be able to help them rebuild. And that will really cause financial burden on families who've put most of their investment into a home, which now is becoming unvaluable. And there are examples already in the UK of cliffs getting eroded away due to large storms and houses then kind of falling into the sea. And I imagine those kind of things will be happening more and more, where you'll see homes not being livable anymore and we'll see people having to move. So we'll see this climate migration happening. And on top of that, of course we do also see sea level rise, which will also kind of be taking away that land that would've been used for homes. So I think it's something that we have to act on and we have to act on today, we're in a very decisive time to do our best to help. 

    Scott Hawkins

    So it sounds very much like, particularly thinking about a country like Australia, the time to act is now. Most of the population lives quite close to the ocean and then a lot of the food sources are then ... it's a very large agricultural country. So it sounds like where we live is not a great place going forward if we don't do enough, and also where we grow our food is not in a great place if things get hotter. Thanks for those insights. A little bit worrying, but I guess all is not lost. So if we do do more, we can at least limit and adapt to the environment that we'll be in. So is there anything that you see that Munich Re can do to be of assistance to the industry and to the community in how we accelerate this discussion and then this adaptation? 

    Caoimhe Adams

    Yeah, definitely. We've been ensuring natural hazards since 1899, so we do have a very good understanding of natural hazards and what we call physical risk. On top of that, we have been one of the first industry players to start mentioning climate change. We had a report on it in the '70s. We've also been one of the ones to propagate that this is a new type of risk, it's something that we cannot use our past data to reflect the future, we need to be taking in scientific developments. We've also worked quite closely with scientific institutions, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, we worked with them twice on two of their reports. We actually got a very small part of a Nobel Peace Prize, working on one of those reports. So we do have a wealth of knowledge when it comes to these natural catastrophes. 

    As Munich Re, we have a responsibility as one of the largest reinsurers in the world to bring what we know in the climate space to the market to help us understand this risk and manage it in the future. So we kind of bring this mix of understanding the hazard, understanding how climate change impacts that hazard from a scientific and from a data-driven perspective. Now what can we do with that? What we can do is we can help you understand the risks that you are facing when it comes to this physical risk of climate change, how these natural hazards are changing. So for example, you could give us your underwriting portfolio or your asset portfolio and we would analyze that and look into what are the different risks that you are facing from these natural hazards. What we can then do with that is understand the financial impacts of those natural hazards and help you make strategic decisions around that. When it comes to underwriting, should you be making different pricing decisions? Should you be assessing different markets, targeting different areas? 

    And then lastly, what we can offer is this managed component where we offer risk transfer solutions. We are a reinsurer, so we can take over that risk that you are not comfortable with. And on top of that, we can do what we've done similarly in the US to these communities, where we offer advice on what kind of resilience measures make sense financially to help be more resilient against the risks of climate change.

    Scott Hawkins

    Yeah. And I think we have definitely a role to play in how to help the community be better going forward. And very much it sounds to me like to be successful in this area, it needs to be a concerted effort. It can't just be government, it can't just be the insurance industry. We really need to focus on those who take the risks, those who finance the risks, those who live in the risks, and then also those who plan where those risks will be into the future. 

    Caoimhe Adams  

    Fully agree. And I think it's up to each and every one of us as well, to not always wait for something to happen, but to take on your role and your responsibility and see what you can do. 

    Scott Hawkins

    Thanks, Caoimhe, it was great chatting with you today and having you on our first ever podcast in this series. 

    Caoimhe Adams

    Thanks so much for having me. 

    Scott Hawkins

    Thank you for listening to the Reinsurance Rendezvous, a podcast by Munich Re. To find out more and to continue the discussion, go to the Munich Re website and look up a recent publication called Natural Disasters in 2022. This will show some staggering statistics and a region by region analysis. Alternatively, visit LinkedIn and search for my blog, Extreme Weather Events. Here I talk about what's driving the current affordability of insurance in this country and what we need to do to create a sustainable and affordable market going forward. Just search on LinkedIn for me, Scott Hawkins at Munich Re. 

    Speaking of which, while you're there, tell me what you think of this podcast. We want to hear from you, our listeners, what are the sorts of topics you'd like to hear discussed, and what are the sorts of guests that you'd like to hear from to inform our future episodes? And stay tuned, the next quarterly episode drops in May. Here, we'll be joined by an industry insider, you'll hear a lively unflinching discussion on the affordability of insurance. To make sure you don't miss any future episodes, subscribe to the Reinsurance Rendezvous on Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts. And while you're there, feel free to leave us a review and a rating. Until next time, thanks for listening, and goodbye for now. 

    Listen to more episodes of Reinsurance Rendezvous

    Learn more about extreme weather